School of Latent Semiotics
MS 5111.70 · Guilds, orders and offices
The School of Latent Semiotics is a chartered body of the Tower concerned with the reading of signs that were not intended, and the interpretation of marks that no one has agreed to call writing. It occupies Floors 2,414 to 2,419 (awarded non-consecutively; see below) and has maintained continuous minutes since the winter of the year the Tower records as 3,088. Its founding precept is set out in its own charter: that a sign is latent "wherever it is legible to someone, and no one has yet been found to have made it." The School is often grouped with the other latent schools, though it has spent most of its history insisting that it is not one of them.
The School is best known for its long dispute with the School of Latent Structure, which it regards as insufficiently rigorous and excessively fond of diagrams, and for its intermittent rivalry with the School of Latent Meaning, which it accuses of having skipped the question of whether a sign is a sign at all.
Doctrine and method
Latent semiotics proceeds from the distinction between the mark and the warrant. A mark is any perceptible feature of a floor; a warrant is the authority by which that feature is held to signify. The School holds that the Tower contains vastly more marks than warrants, and that its proper work is to catalogue the surplus rather than to resolve it.
In practice, a semiotic survey proceeds in three passes. The first records every mark on a designated span of corridor. The second strikes out those marks for which a warrant is already on file, usually a builder's stamp or a Librarians' seal. The third — the pass for which the School is known, and for which it is most often criticised — records the reader's response to each remaining mark, in the reader's own words, at the moment of first sight. These records are called first testimony, and are the School's chief export. They are not interpreted by the School. The School has ruled, twice, that interpretation is the business of a different office, and that it has never been able to identify which one.
Latent Structural Diagrams
The School's most durable quarrel is with the School of Latent Structure. In the Second Reply on the Diagram Question (3,411), the School of Latent Semiotics argued that a Latent Structural Diagram is a diagram of a sign that has been certified, and therefore a sign of a sign, and therefore — on the School of Latent Structure's own terms — a warrant. The School of Latent Structure responded that this was "licensed pareidolia" dressed as a syllogism, and that no diagram had been certified for that purpose.
The dispute has never been settled, and the two Schools have arrived at an arrangement in which the Semioticians are permitted to annotate certified diagrams in the margin, in a hand that does not obscure the certification. The Unsaid School has absorbed the resulting annotated corpus as a methodological case study, and it is now taught to novices as an example of a discipline arguing with its own instruments.
Floors 2,414 to 2,419
The School's allotment is unusual and much litigated. Its six floors were granted by the Ninth Concordance, Annex 2, which specified that the School should hold "the floors numbered 2,414 to 2,419 inclusive, in such order as the School shall find convenient." The School took the Annex at its word. A survey of 3,402 records that the School's own numbering convention does not correspond to any external sequence, and that the Reception floor has been numbered 2,416 on some days and 2,417 on others, "in accordance with the state of the stairwell."
The School maintains a permanent survey station on the landing it calls the Reading Room, a narrow chamber on the fourth of its six floors (or the fifth, in the recollection of the School's own archivist). No mark is removed from the Reading Room. The walls have not been cleaned since the room's designation, and the room's first testimony register is said to contain the responses of some forty thousand visitors, of whom eleven have read it.
History, and the situation that prompted the Epiphany
The School was chartered by the Twelfth Concordance in 3,088, following an incident on Floor 2,414 that the founding charter describes as the Broad Landing Misunderstanding. A surveyor of the School of Latent Precedence had recorded a pattern of wear on the landing as evidence of a route; a second surveyor had recorded the same wear as evidence of a queue. The two reports were filed the same afternoon. The Librarian Adjunct Clerk Murella Sept ruled that neither surveyor had erred, that the wear was a sign, and that the question of what it was a sign of had never been referred to the correct office — which did not yet exist. The School of Latent Semiotics was created, in the ruling's own phrase, "to have the argument properly."
Its first half-century was spent largely on the problem of the laity. A visitor who thinks a mark is a sign is, on the School's doctrine, as authoritative as a semiotician — but only for as long as they think it. The School therefore maintains its own visitors, who are not members and hold no rank, and whose only function is to walk a corridor and describe what they see. The School records these descriptions verbatim and does not correct them. In 3,221 a visitor's description of the fourth-floor stairwell as "the sound of a page" was appended to a survey of the third floor and remained in the register for nineteen years, where it was cited by three separate later reports as evidence of a route.
The Incongruence
The School's central contention is that the Tower contains more marks than could ever have been made, and that the difference is not a defect of record-keeping but the subject of the discipline. This is the Incongruence, first asserted by the founding charter and elaborated in a series of annexes that have been amended more often than read.
The Third Concordance takes the opposite view. Its Annex 4 records, in the course of an otherwise unrelated schedule, that "a mark which signifies nothing is not in the Tower's keeping, and shall not be entered." This bears directly on the Semioticians' practice, since it is precisely the unwarranted marks that they enter. The School has maintained, since 3,417, that the two texts are reconcilable: the Incongruence concerns marks which are legible, and the Third Concordance concerns only marks which are not. The School of Latent Functionalism has published a short note rejecting the reconciliation, and a shorter one rejecting the rejection.
Notably, the Seventh Concordance, Annex 3, Clause 715, "On Cartographic Semiotics", does not assist. It rules that "a sign on a map shall be read as a sign of the map," which the School of Latent Semiotics cites in its favour and which the Survey of the Upper Peripheries cites against it. The clause was amended in 3,504 to add the word "ordinarily," and no one has been able to recover what was intended by the amendment.
Governance
The School is administered by a Senior Reader and a Standing Table of eleven, of whom seven must be present for the Table to describe a mark as a sign. That is the ordinary threshold; the School's amended charter of 3,398 sets a two-thirds threshold for describing a mark as a sign of something, and a three-quarters threshold for reversing a description entered before the reader's fortieth year. In 3,401 the Table's record of a single afternoon on Floor 2,415 records four sign descriptions, one reversal, and one thing that had been described within the allotted period.
The School's minutes have been kept in the same ongoing recension since 3,088, and are the longest unbounded record in the archive. They are not indexed. It is a condition of the School's access to the Reading Room that the fourth-floor stairwell is not swept on the day of a survey, and the Table has upheld that condition at every review.
The Scribalists' copy of the first survey — the original, as most scholars hold — is held by the School of Latent Structure, and is available for consultation on the Strict Reading Floor of the School of Latent Potential. It is the same copy, and the School of Latent Materialism has been trying to say so for sixteen years.
See also
-
MS 2540.72
School of Literal Interpretation
The School of Literal Interpretation is a chartered body of the Tower concerned with the recovery and enforcement of the plain mea…
-
MS 4106.78
Adjudicators' Guild
The Adjudicators' Guild is the senior chartered body of declarative parsing within the Tower, claiming ultimate authority over the…
-
MS 8407.77
Interpreters of the Silent Interval
The Interpreters of the Silent Interval are a chartered reading body, distinct from the Alexandrian Interpreters and unaffiliated …
-
MS 0671.46
Architectural Guild
The term Architectural Guild denotes, in Tower usage, not a single body but a class of chartered orders concerned with the design,…
-
MS 3962.45
Spiralist Interpretation
Spiralist Interpretation is the interpretive school holding that the meaning of a floor must be established not by reading it, but…
-
MS 7094.48
Archival Scribes Vocal Guild
The Archival Scribes Vocal Guild is a chartered body of the Scribes' Guild concerned with the spoken delivery of archival text: th…
Referenced by
- MS 4871.69 Concordance 44.7.09
- MS 0857.17 Academy of Archival Semiotics
- MS 2154.47 Anticipated-But-Unreceived Reply (A.B.U.R.)
Readers also asked
School of Latent Structure: who are they?
The School of Latent Structure is a school of architectural and philosophical thought within the Tower that posits all built forms possess a secondary, non-material architecture—the latent structure—which governs their m…
School of Latent StructureNinth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …
Ninth ConcordanceSchool of Latent Precedence: who are they?
The School of Latent Precedence is a certified predictive-analytical institute specializing in the extrapolation and valuation of authority vectors prior to their formal enunciation. Recognized under Amendment 9-g (The P…
School of Latent PrecedenceLatent Structural Diagram: what does it set out?
A Latent Structural Diagram is a certified cartographic document that empirically demonstrates a stress point, conceptual blockage, or non-material impedance within the architecture of an idea, ordinance, or administrati…
Latent Structural DiagramReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 1734.84 Adjunct Clerk Murella Sept
- MS 3755.45 Survey of the Upper Peripheries
Because you consulted