The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Quorum Convening

MS 6393.33 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and scope

Quorum Convening is the procedure by which the standing bodies of the Tower are lawfully assembled, and the corresponding body of instruction governing what counts as assembled. It is distinguished from Review by Quorum in that convening concerns the existence of a quorum, while review concerns what a quorum, once it exists, is permitted to do. The distinction is not observed by every office. The Third Concordance treats the two under a single heading, Annex 4, and the Quorum of Imminence has cited this consolidation in support of its claim to review its own convening.

Convening is administered in ordinary circumstances by the Office of the Roll, a single desk on the seventh landing of the western stack, staffed continuously since at least 3,900 by a succession of clerks whose names are recorded only by seat. No seat has been vacant for more than four days.

The Roll and its amendments

Each body maintains a Roll of Convenable Members. A convocation is valid when the number of members present equals or exceeds the quorum stated for that body on the Roll as amended. The difficulty, long acknowledged and never resolved, is that a member may be recorded as convenable on one Roll and struck from another, because the Rolls are amended by their own bodies and amendments take effect on the date of the meeting at which they are read, which is frequently a meeting that the amendment in question would have rendered invalid.

The Ink-Stained Quorum arose from precisely this difficulty in the winter of 4418, when an amendment admitted eleven members to the Roll after the meeting had already failed for want of eleven. The members remained in their seats. The clerk recorded the meeting as two meetings, of which the first was not convened and the second was. Both entries survive; the second is the one commonly cited.

"Where a body has failed to convene, and its members have not dispersed, the meeting shall be read as having convened at the moment the amendment admitting them was read, and the interval shall be treated as a recess."

— Third Concordance, Annex 4, clause 7

The vow of unspoken assembly and the Silent Conclave

Convening the Librarians’ Silent Conclave presents a difficulty of a different order. The Conclave convenes without speech, and its Rolls are kept by a clerk who is not permitted to ask which of those present intend to be counted. Attendance is established by a count of chairs occupied at the first bell and again at the third, and a member who arrives between bells is counted if a seat remains, and if it does not, is not. Odile Mandevant proposed in her Memorandum on Convening in Absence that a seat vacated during the interval be left vacant until the session closes, on the reasoning that a count is not a count if it is conducted twice. The Memorandum was received and filed. The double count continues.

The Quorum of Silence, by contrast, convenes by certification. Its nine Certifying Auditors assemble, and their assembly is not a quorum until one of them certifies that it is; the certifier must be among those counted. During the Affair of the Silent Quorum the Quorum certified a silence during a ruling by the Quorum of Imminence, and the question of whether a quorum can certify its own convening in the course of business conducted under that convening was raised and left open. The Doctrine of Implied Quorum was never formally adopted or rejected by the Quorum of Silence, and the third clerk of the Roll has noted, in a marginal hand of 4421, that this is because the Quorum can no longer convene to decide the question except under the Doctrine.

Convening in absence

Absent members may be convened by notice left at their registered stair, and are counted as convenable for the purpose of the Roll though not, evidently, for the purpose of a count of chairs. The Quorum of Imminence reenacts the Edict of Silent Quorum at the opening of each session, a formality performed before the reading of the Roll and therefore before it is established that anyone is entitled to perform it. The Office of the Roll has declined to rule on this, observing that the Edict has never been performed at a session that did not subsequently convene.

Disputed points

Scholars differ as to whether the twelve-hour notice required by the Standing Orders of 4004 attaches to the member or to the seat. The Roll Office holds the seat, and has convened on notice delivered to a member's stair while the member was three floors below it, on the ground that the stair is served. A minority reading, advanced in the Scriptorium Recensions and never withdrawn, holds that a member who can be reached by bell is convened by the bell, and that the notices are a courtesy.

It is further disputed whether a convocation dissolved for want of a quorum may be reconvened on the same day. Annex 4 permits it. The Third Concordance is silent. The Ratification Quorum has declined to ratify any reconvening held within the day, and the Seventh Quorum of Scribes, never invited to sit with the Ratification Quorum, has not been asked to comment.

The Office of the Roll keeps a box of unread notices returned from stair 44C, which has no door. They are retained, per the desk's standing instruction, in case the stair is opened.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Ratification Quorum: who are they?
Affair of the Silent Quorum: what happened?

The Affair of the Silent Quorum was a protracted administrative and ontological dispute within the Librarians, precipitated by the routine—and subsequently controversial—application of the Doctrine of Implied Quorum. The…

Affair of the Silent Quorum
Review by Quorum: how is it conducted?

Review by Quorum is the standing procedure by which a convened or implied body of the Tower examines a holding, ruling, or floor condition and issues a binding annotation upon the archive. First codified in the Second Re…

Review by Quorum
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.