The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Procedural Clause

MS 0347.73 · Practices and doctrines

A Procedural Clause is any numbered provision of the Tower's administrative Concordances that governs how other provisions are to be read, applied, suspended, or replaced, as distinct from a substantive clause, which governs the matter at hand. The distinction is old, universally invoked, and nowhere defined in a surviving text. Procedural Clauses are numbered within the clause sequence of their parent Concordance but are indexed separately by the Office of Clause Registration, which maintains the only complete list and has twice declined to publish it on the grounds that the list is itself procedural.

Definition and the problem of the definition

The earliest attempt at a definition appears in the preamble to the Third Concordance, which describes procedural clauses as "those provisions which, if removed, would leave the remaining provisions unchanged in substance and unreadable in practice" (Third Concordance, Preamble, para. 4). The formulation has been cited in every subsequent dispute on the question and has settled none of them. Procedural Atomism (Clause 5) holds that the operative force of a Concordance resides in its procedural clauses alone, a position that would render every substantive clause decorative; the School of Literal Correspondence has never forgiven it.

In practice a clause is procedural if the Office of Clause Registration has entered it in the procedural register, and it is entered if two Librarians of the Fifth Recension attest that it is procedural. The attestation form contains no field for the clause's content. Clerk Amsel Veyr, who kept the register from the winter of 408 to the spring of 419, recorded in his day-book that he had attested eleven clauses in a single morning "on the understanding that they were short" (Veyr, Register Day-Book, entry for 3 Firstfrost 412).

Amendment and the Self-Referential Proviso

Because procedural clauses govern amendment, they are amended under procedures that are themselves procedural clauses. The Self-Referential Proviso states the rule plainly: any procedural clause may be amended only by a procedure described in a procedural clause. The Proviso does not say which procedural clause, and the resulting latitude has produced the long-running dispute between the reading that any procedural clause suffices (the Loose Recension) and the reading that only the clause under which the amendment was originally made will do (the Strict Recension). The Strict Recension has the better argument and the smaller following.

Clause 7 of the administrative Concordances is the most heavily amended procedural clause in the Tower; its sub-clauses Clause 7.1.5 and Clause 7.1.6 have between them been amended forty-one times, and the Clause 7 Inspectors now carry both versions and a separate card index of which floors observe which. Clause 19 is understood to be in oppositional tension with Clause 5, though the nature of the tension is disputed; the Declaration of Procedural Anomaly treats the opposition as settled and classifies it, at Annex D, Clause 7, as Procedural Nostalgia.

Notable procedural clauses

A short inventory is maintained by the Office for the convenience of expeditions:

Contradiction and the Protocol

Where two procedural clauses conflict, the Contradiction Protocol Clause 7 requires that both be applied in the order of their registration and the discrepancy noted in the margin of the later one. The margin note is the only part of the operation that is inspected. Clause 812 was registered twice, eleven years apart, in error, and for a period of nine months in 436 both registrations governed Floor 44 concurrently; the floor's sealing office issued documents under each and reconciled them by sealing one copy of everything and storing the other. The second registration was not annulled. It was reclassified as substantive, which took it out of the Protocol's reach and left the discrepancy standing.

"A clause may be procedural, or it may be substantive, or it may be both; the third case is an error of the register and must be corrected by the register."

— Clause 8.α.7, marginal ruling of the Fifth Recension

The Veyr grievance

In the winter of 416 Veyr attested a clause he had not read, on the strength of a colleague's assurance that it concerned stairwell lighting. It concerned the disposition of petitions. The clause stood for six years before the error was discovered, at which point the petitions decided under it were held to have been decided properly, since the attestation had been regular and the register had not been corrected. Veyr petitioned for the register to be corrected retroactively and was refused under a procedural clause dealing with the correction of registers, which he had himself attested in 408. He spent his remaining tenure drafting a memorandum distinguishing procedural clauses from the procedure of procedural clauses; it runs to one hundred and forty folios and is filed, unclassified, in the open stacks of Floor 271.

The register has been kept continuously since, and the attestation form now carries a line for the clause's subject. It is left blank in approximately one case in three.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Contradiction Protocol Clause 7: what does it set out?

Contradiction Protocol Clause 7 is the enactment clause of the Contradiction Protocol, the provision by which an anomaly already recognized as procedural is converted into an anomaly formally in dispute. It is the only c…

Contradiction Protocol Clause 7
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Clause 7.1.5: what does it set out?

Clause 7.1.5 is a procedural sub-clause within Clause 7 of the Tower’s administrative Concordances. It concerns the classification and disposition of inferred holdings—catalogued items whose existence is deduced solely f…

Clause 7.1.5
Clause 19, Annex B: what does it set out?

ClauseĠ19,ĠAnnexĠBĠisĠtheĠadministrativeĠframeworkĠgoverningĠtheĠproceduralĠsystemĠofĠmatriculationĠforĠnewlyĠidentifiedĠholdingsĠwithinĠtheĠTower.ĠFormallyĠratifiedĠunderĠtheĠauspicesĠofĠtheĠThirdĠConcordance,ĠitĠdefine…

Clause 19, Annex B

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.