Principle of Discreteness
MS 2799.50 · Practices and doctrines
The Principle of Discreteness is a governing practice of the Tower holding that two distinct jurisdictions cannot occupy the same conceptual-locational axis without generating a formal dissonance. It is among the oldest of the working principles and is cited in nearly every dispute in which a floor, stair, or landing is claimed by more than one office. The Principle does not forbid such claims. It merely requires that where two jurisdictions meet on a single axis, the resulting dissonance be recorded, sealed, and entered against a numbered file before either party may act. In this respect the Principle of Discreteness is less a rule of settlement than a rule of bookkeeping, and it has been observed that the Tower has settled very little and recorded a great deal.
Formulation and early recensions
The Principle first appears in the Fourth Recension of the Working Principles, clause 12, in a form short enough to be copied onto a handrail: "Two things may not be one place." Later recensions expand this considerably. The Fifth Recension added the requirement of a Formal Dissonance Register, and the Ninth Recension appended the doctrine of the Displaced Axis, which holds that when a dispute cannot be resolved on its own axis, the axis itself may be relocated and the dispute carried with it. The Displaced Axis is frequently invoked in jurisdictional disputes concerning the Principle, and is responsible for the celebrated case of the Bracketed Landing on Floor Sable 19, which was moved twice and disputed three times and is presently claimed by no one.
Relation to adjacent principles
The Principle of Discreteness is distinguished carefully from the Principle of Contiguous Meaning, which governs the joining of things rather than their separation, and from the Theobold Principle, which addresses the residue left behind when a separation is imperfectly performed. Clerks are frequently confused on this point; the Gervaise Principle is often cited as a corrective, though the corrective itself requires the offending clerk to read the Gervaise Principle, which few do. The Principle is also held to stand behind the Principle of Unbroken Continuity in cases where a boundary is disputed but not severed. Where a boundary is severed entirely, the Selvage Principle takes precedence, and the Discreteness file is closed without prejudice. Discreteness abuts the Principle of Referential Integrity but does not depend on it: the former concerns the placement of jurisdictions, the latter the conditions under which their referents may be said to exist.
The Sable 19 winter and the Voss grievance
In the winter of the year recorded as Concordance Year 4112, two offices — the Bureau of Stair Inventory and the Office of Landing Titles — claimed the same stair for the same season. The Bureau maintained that the stair was an inventory item and therefore subject to its count; the Office maintained that the stair was a title and therefore subject to its register. Neither office would concede the axis. The resulting dissonance was entered, as required, on the Formal Dissonance Register, where it remained for eleven months because the Register's custodian, Clerk Marrow Voss, refused to accept the entry on the grounds that it had been written in the wrong ink.
"A dissonance entered in the wrong ink is not entered at all, and a dispute not entered is not a dispute but a noise."
— Clerk Marrow Voss, letter to the Bureau of Stair Inventory, Concordance Year 4112
The Bureau replied that the ink had been specified by Concordance 88 and that Voss's preferred ink had been struck by Concordance 91. Voss observed that Concordance 91 was itself struck by the Concordance of the Following Year and that the Bureau had not noticed. The matter was eventually referred to the Librarians, who ruled that the dispute had in fact been settled by the displacement of the axis on the third day and that neither office had been told. The stair was subsequently found on Floor Sable 22, where it remains. Clerk Voss was reassigned to the Lower Scriptorium and is reported to have taken the Register with him.
Disputed readings
The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether the Principle requires two distinct jurisdictions or merely two jurisdictions asserting distinctness. The Concordance of the Narrow Reading (clause 4) holds the former: the jurisdictions must genuinely be separate before a dissonance can arise. The Concordance of the Broad Reading (clause 4) holds the latter, which permits a single jurisdiction to generate a dissonance against itself where its own records disagree. The Broad Reading has been used since Concordance Year 4231 to justify the practice of searching a floor twice and entering both results, and the Principle of Bureaucratic Closure depends in part on it. The Narrow Reading is preferred by the Office of Landing Titles and the Broad by the Bureau of Stair Inventory, which has been observed to constitute a dissonance of its own.
A secondary dispute concerns the status of a dissonance once the parties have both perished or been reassigned. The Principle of Unbroken Custody would ordinarily keep the file open, but the Vanishing Principle removes the parties from the record entirely, and the Principle of Deferred Judgment instructs that the file be held rather than closed. The Principle of Suspension permits a Provisional Holding Number to be issued in such cases; the number is valid until the parties return or are formally forgotten, and there are at present some four thousand such numbers outstanding.
Practices of observance
Offices observing the Principle are required to maintain an axis statement, renewed each Concordance, and to post a notice at the junction of any shared jurisdiction. The notice is to be removed once the dissonance is entered. It is not permitted to enter a dissonance on a landing during the hours of the Stair Count, and the notice may not be posted on a stair that is currently being counted. Clerks have found this restriction difficult in practice, since a stair being counted is precisely the stair most often in dispute, and the Standard Ruling on Counted Stairs has been applied more than nine hundred times without resolving the question. The Tower has at least provided, in Concordance 214, that a stair counted twice in a season need not be counted a third time, and clerks have taken what comfort from this they can.
See also Principle of the Displaced Axis, Formal Dissonance Register, Principle of Contained Vericity, Principle of Recursive Integrity, and the Concordances of the Sable Floors.
See also
-
MS 2582.87
Expeditionary Protocols for Non-Sequential Floors
The core principle underlying all non-sequential protocols is the assumption of ordinal dissonance. This is the administrative rec…
-
MS 7762.53
Locational Quarantines
Locational Quarantines refer to the procedural and physical containment of spaces, objects, or phenomena exhibiting a type of loca…
-
MS 0671.98
Principle of Direct Adjacency
The Principle of Direct Adjacency is a procedural axiom within the Forty-Seventh Concordance governing the spatial and conceptual …
-
MS 3153.10
Principle of Attenuated Interaction
Principle of Attenuated Interaction (sometimes referred to as the Attenuated Motif Doctrine) is a Concordance-level axiom governin…
-
MS 1276.60
Algorithm of Shifting Annexes
The Algorithm of Shifting Annexes is the procedural mechanism responsible for generating the daily physical and conceptual coordin…
-
MS 7183.00
Clause 12
Clause 12 is a principle of administrative recursion within the Tower’s Concordance system, formally titled "On the Perpetual Requ…
Referenced by
- MS 8282.11 Principle of the Displaced Axis
- MS 1766.34 The Principle of the Displaced Axis
Readers also asked
Principle of Bureaucratic Closure: how is it conducted?
Vanishing Principle Practice: how is it conducted?
Vanishing Principle Practice is the body of procedural custom, adjudicative habit, and scriptorial routine by which the Vanishing Principle is applied within the Tower's administrative and ontological registers. It is di…
Vanishing Principle PracticeBracketed Landing: where is it?
The Bracketed Landing is a landing of record on Sable 19, consisting at present of a single step, a handrail of eleven balusters, and a square of floor variously measured at four feet by four feet and at nothing at all. …
Bracketed LandingPrinciple of Unbroken Continuity: how is it conducted?
The Principle is built upon three axiomatic statements:
Principle of Unbroken ContinuityPassages cited from this record
-
A dissonance entered in the wrong ink is not entered at all, and a dispute not entered is not a dispute but a noise.
Clerk Marrow Voss, letter to the Bureau of Stair Inventory, Concordance Year 4112
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2301.74 Clerk Marrow Voss
- MS 0695.09 Sable 19
- MS 7803.47 Concordance of the Following Year
- MS 8378.77 Fourth Recension of the Working Principles
Because you consulted