The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Predicate Coherence Check

MS 0646.10 · Practices and doctrines

The Predicate Coherence Check is the fourth procedural stage of the Formal Consistency Check, convened between the Crossreferential Stability Check and the Dimensional Calibration Check. It assesses whether the predicates under which a floor, document, or office is catalogued may be simultaneously asserted of the same subject without the record collapsing into contradiction. It is not, and has never been, an inquiry into whether the predicates are true. A floor may be catalogued as both "Unlit" and "Luminous" and pass the Predicate Coherence Check without correction, provided the record is prepared to say where and when each applies. This distinction was drawn by Librarian Ostrec Vane in the annotative matter to the Second Concordance, and it is repeated at the head of every Predicate Coherence Check return issued since the winter of 611.

The Check is administered by the Bureau of Axiomatic Purity, which received it by transfer from the Office of First Description in 447 and has disputed the terms of the transfer ever since.

Procedure

A return is docketed on the standard narrow slate and must name the subject, the predicates asserted of it, and the source of each predicate. The presiding clerk then tests the set in three passes: for direct conflict, for entailment conflict, and for what the Bureau calls "residual pairing," in which two predicates that do not conflict are nonetheless found to have been asserted of the subject by offices that have never agreed about the subject's existence. Where all three passes clear, the return is sealed and forwarded to the Notarization Check, without which the Second Verification Amp Concordance Check cannot be convened.

Where a pass fails, the clerk does not resolve the conflict. The clerk assigns a Predicate Variance Marker, number it, and enters it in the Variance Ledger of the originating floor. A single floor may hold up to nine open markers. The tenth is not refused but is affixed to the door of the floor itself, in ink, and this is why visitors are asked to keep to the outer walkways of floors bearing door-markers and to conduct their reading from the landing.

History

The Check originated as a dispute between cataloguers. In 441, two Librarians — Sarn of the Ninth Landing and Vane, then still a junior annotator — independently described the same storey as "self-indexing" and as "indexed only by the office below," and neither recension would yield. The matter reached the Archival Seals Office, which declined to break the tie on the grounds that both descriptions were coherently held. The office's ruling of 6 Ember 441 is the founding document of the present procedure:

"The Seal does not determine which clerk is correct, being unable to do so and uninterested in the attempt. It determines only that the record may continue to bear both descriptions, numbered separately, and that neither may be struck until the floor is resurveyed."

— Archival Seals Office, Ruling 441/9, annexed to Concordance 3

The phrase "numbered separately" became the Predicate Variance Marker, and the requirement that neither be struck became the Check's founding prohibition. The Codex I later reaffirmed the arrangement in its clause on unverified reliefs, though whether that clause applies to markers or only to reliefs is disputed — see below.

The Vane–Ostrec dispute

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns what the Check is actually testing. Librarian Ostrec Vane held, in the annotative matter to the Second Concordance and again in a memorandum of 623, that the Check tests the record's willingness to specify conditions — that a coherent record is one that can say "Unlit by night, Luminous by requisition" without embarrassment. Sarn of the Ninth Landing, in a rebuttal circulated privately and later printed as Sarn's Objection, held that the Check tests the subject, and that a floor which is Unlit by night and Luminous by requisition is not coherently described but is two floors described in one entry.

The Bureau of Axiomatic Purity has never ruled between them. Its standing notice of 704 refers to the question as "presently unresolved and not obstructive," a formulation that has itself been the subject of eleven Predicate Variance Markers.

Interactions with adjacent offices

The Check's relationship with the Conflict Check is fixed but asymmetric. The Conflict Check convenes its three mandatory stages in fixed succession and does not consult the Predicate Coherence Check at any point; the Predicate Coherence Check, by contrast, will not clear a return in which a conflict has been found but not numbered. Clerks who have attempted to reverse this arrangement have been referred to the Procedural Harmony Check, which is not a tribunal and says so on its door.

Frequency of returns is recorded by floor and by quarter, and the distribution is uneven. Floor 1,204 has produced no admissible return since 588, its cataloguers maintaining that the floor is "described once and sufficiently." Floor 1,205 has produced eleven thousand.

Maintenance

Slates are resurfaced every third year by the Slateworks of the Lower Register. They are not to be wiped with the sleeve.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Conflict Check: how is it conducted?

Conflict Check is a multi-stage administrative protocol mandated by Registry and performed by the Department of Procedural Integrity for any Procedural Conflict or substantive dispute that cannot be resolved by citing a …

Conflict Check
Second Verification Amp Concordance Check: how is it conducted?

The Second Verification Amp Concordance Check is the third-stage instrument by which a document already verified once may be verified again against the text of the Second Concordance, and is distinguished from every othe…

Second Verification Amp Concordance Check
Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians
Dimensional Calibration Check: what happened?

The Dimensional Calibration Check is the terminal examination of any aperture proposed for regulated use, conducted to establish that the space a traveller enters is the space the aperture's registration claims. It is di…

Dimensional Calibration Check

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.