The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Post-Entry Harmonization

MS 5283.71 · Practices and doctrines

Post-Entry Harmonization is the collective term for the procedures by which a record already entered in the Tower's catalogues is brought into agreement with itself, with its neighbours, and with the floors on which it is shelved. It is distinguished from initial entry — the act of cataloguing a subject — by the principle set out in Resolution 12, ratified 17 Ventos, 842 (Post-Cataloguing), that no entry is ever wrong, only early. Post-Entry Harmonization exists to correct for this earliness.

The term was formally fixed in the Ninth Concordance, Annex 11, which defines the practice as "the retroactive adjustment of an entered record such that its earlier statements may continue to have been accurate" (Ninth Concordance, Annex 11, cl. 2). Practitioners are drawn from the Panel of Harmonization and, in acoustic cases, from the Acoustic Harmonization Guild; designation disputes are referred across to the Office of Designation Harmonization, which sits two floors below and does not accept stairs-facing deliveries before the ninth bell.

Origin and jurisdiction

Post-Entry Harmonization was not, in its earliest form, a harmonization at all. It began as a ledger-keeping remedy on Floor 2044, where entries concerning the winter of 811 had been catalogued out of order and could not thereafter be shelved in the sequence their own text assumed. The librarian of that floor, Ceres Anwyl, proposed that the entries be amended rather than re-shelved, on the grounds that the shelves were load-bearing and the entries were not. Her memorandum of 14 Dreml, 813 — the earliest document in the practice's register — remains the standard citation for the priority of text over furniture (Anwyl, Memorandum on the Winter Entries, Floor 2044 scriptorium, fol. 6r).

Authority over the practice was contested for some eighty years between the Office of Designation Harmonization and the Panel of Harmonization. The dispute was settled in favour of the Panel by Post-Vigil Reporting conventions of 894, on the reasoning that an entry concluded and reported could not afterwards be reopened for naming, but only for fine adjustment. Post-Entry Harmonization therefore proceeds only on entries whose Post-Vigil Report has already been interred, and proceeds gently. Where a designation is itself found to be at fault, the record is passed to the Office of Designation Harmonization and the entry is regarded as never having concluded — a state the registers describe, without irony, as "the long tail."

The tiers of adjustment

Adjustment is graded. Minor adjustment — a corrected date, a repaired cross-reference — may be undertaken by the floor librarian alone. Moderate adjustment, which alters a claim a reader might have acted upon, requires the concurrence of two Librarians and the presence of a witness whose name is recorded but not published. Full adjustment, in which the entry's central claim is amended and its appendices renumbered, is reserved to Tier VII: Full Contextual Harmonization, and its use on any floor below the 1900s requires the personal seal of the Presiding Harmonizer. The seal has been used eleven times since 842. Nine of the eleven were in the same winter. The winter is not recorded in the general reckoning, only in the appendices of the relevant floors.

Acoustic procedures form a separate column of the schedule. Contextual Harmonization by sound is permitted where two entries contradict each other in tone but not in substance, and the contradiction may be resolved by the sounding of one against the other in a closed chamber. The chambers on Floor 701 are maintained by the Acoustic Harmonization Guild and are unsuitable for any other purpose. Readers are reminded that the chambers are not to be entered with food.

Procedure and the record of amendment

Every adjustment is entered in a running amendment register kept beside the original. The register is cumulative: an entry amended four times will carry four lines, and the reader is expected to read all four before relying on any single statement in the article above them. The Tower does not consider this burdensome. The Registry of Recursive Processes records that amendment registers may themselves be amended, and that the amendment of an amendment register is not to be confused with the amendment of the entry to which it refers — a distinction the Post of Recursive Oversight was created to police, and which it has policed, by its own account, without incident since entry 4-12-Ȣ.α (Post-Anchoring).

Disputes over whether an amendment has in fact taken place are settled by Edict 4117-γ, which provides that an amendment is in force from the moment the register line is ruled, and not from the moment it is written. The Edict is deliberately silent on erasure. In practice erasure confers an intermediate status, and the affected entries are said to be "in pencil," though no pencil has been used in the Tower's registers since the retirement of clerk Idris Maun in 903, who had used one for forty years and whose pencil was afterwards catalogued on Floor 1188 under a subject of its own.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal controversy concerns retroactivity. The Ninth Concordance holds that a harmonized entry was always correct and that the amendment merely reveals it. The Eleventh Concordance, written later and read less, holds the opposite: that the entry was incorrect and now is not, and that the amendment is a genuine change in the record. The two positions cannot both be held. The Bureau of Temporal Harmonization has declined to arbitrate, noting in its circular of 18 Ostrel, 921, that the question "lies within the Tower's own time and is therefore not ours to adjust" (Bureau circular 44-B, § 3).

A minority position, associated with the School of Empirical Harmonization, holds that the question is unmeasurable and should not be asked. Its pamphlet, On Not Asking (4th recension, 948), argues that "an entry which has been amended, cited, and shelved is in agreement with its floor, whatever it was before; the before is a shelf-mark, not a fact" (On Not Asking, 4th recension, § 9). The pamphlet is shelved under disagreement.

Notable cases

The Piscolt entry of 857 is the standard example. The entry recorded a subject as residing on Floor 1602; the subject's own appendix, entered on the same day, placed it on Floor 1602 as well, but the two documents differed as to which side of the corridor. Harmonization proceeded by simple amendment of the corridor, which was found to be recorded incorrectly in the floor survey and correctly in both entries. The floor survey was amended. The corridor was not moved. Visiting parties were redirected for the remainder of the year.

A second case, the Vellum of 879, concerned an entry whose appendix had been entered before the entry itself, so that the harmonization had, in effect, already occurred. The Panel ruled that the appendix be adjusted to agree with the entry it preceded, and that the entry be left undisturbed, and that no further action be taken. Nothing was done. The case is cited in the training of new Librarians as an instance of harmonization by omission, a category the Harmonization schedule lists but does not explain.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Designation Harmonization: who are they?

The Office of Designation Harmonization is a public-facing bureau housed in Circuit Epsilon of the Spiral 7 administrative complex, charged with the reconciliation of names, titles, and catalogical designations that have…

Office of Designation Harmonization
Registry of Recursive Processes: what does it set out?

Registry of Recursive Processes is the primary meta-registry maintained by the Guild of Procedural Archivists to catalogue all recursive processes sanctioned for operation within The Tower. Its entries define the scope, …

Registry of Recursive Processes
Post of Recursive Oversight: who are they?

The Post of Recursive Oversight is a clerical office within the Bureau of Recursive Affairs, established per Registry of Recursive Processes entry 4-12-Ȣ.α (Post-Anchoring) to fulfill the principle of post-Collation admi…

Post of Recursive Oversight
Contextual Harmonization: how is it conducted?

Contextual Harmonization is the administrative procedure by which the conceptual framework of a newly catalogued subject is reconciled with the established contextual parameters of its assigned floor. Governed primarily …

Contextual Harmonization

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.