The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Ottiline Brae

MS 8086.37 · Persons

Overview

Ottiline Brae was a scribe of the middle scriptoria, active during the period covered by the Fourth Concordance, and remembered almost entirely for a single adverse precedent entered against her name in Annex 11 of that document. The precedent concerns the closing of a folio after the hour appointed for its closure, and has since been cited in connection with forty-one subsequent disputes, none of which, on the record, involved Brae herself. She is not otherwise listed among the signatories of any surviving Concordance, nor does she appear in the roll of scriptoria officers for the relevant cycles.

Brae's name is frequently confused in the archive with those of Ottiline Verrick, Ottiline Vey, and the several other Ottilines whose forename recurs without evident etymological cause. Readers are advised that the Tower maintains no consolidated Ottiline register, and that attempts to construct one have twice been abandoned at the behest of the Librarian-Taxonomist's Office.

The Annex 11 precedent

The Fourth Concordance, Annex 11, records a ruling against a scribe named Ottiline Brae for closing her folio late. The Annex does not state the hour of closure, the hour appointed, the floor on which the folio was held, or the identity of the official who observed the lapse. What it does state is the consequence: that a folio closed after its appointed hour is thereafter treated as having been closed at no time, and that the matter of its contents reverts to the standing of unentered material.

The drafting of Annex 11 has been attributed, on slender evidence, to the clerical circle surrounding Ottiline Vey, though Ninth Concordance Annex 3 places the composition in an earlier hand. The Seventh Concordance refers to the ruling obliquely, as "the Brae provision," without reproducing its terms, which has led at least one commentator to suppose that the provision was understood differently in the generations following its entry.

"A folio closed late is a folio not closed; and a folio not closed is a folio that may be reopened by anyone who finds it."

— Fourth Concordance, Annex 11

Later citations

The Annex 11 precedent was invoked during the dispute over the Somnolent Folio, where it was argued unsuccessfully that a folio asleep for eleven days should be deemed unclosed on analogous grounds. It was invoked again in the matter of Registrar Ottiline Vash's refusal to close volume 907 of the working ledger, though here the analogy cut against the invoking party: the volume in question had been opened in error and belonged to a different floor entirely.

A third and more consequential citation occurred in the Pre-Dawn Evacuation of Y203 SCE, when staff of the Central Pneumatic Stacks attempted to treat all open folios as having been never closed, and therefore as not requiring evacuation. The argument was received coolly. The subsequent Archival Evacuation proceeded on ordinary principles, and the folios in question were moved to the Whispering Stacks Corridor for interim storage.

Disputed identity

Whether Ottiline Brae and the "Brae" of Annex 11 are the same person is not settled. The counter-argument, most fully set out in the marginalia to the Kappa Fragment and attributed by Ottiline Merrow to a junior clerk's hand, holds that "Brae" was a place or a shelf designation rather than a name, and that the Annex therefore records a folio closed late somewhere in Brae rather than by anyone called Brae.

The Fourth Concordance itself does not resolve the question, and the office charged with maintaining such distinctions has noted that the distinction, if it exists, changes nothing about the ruling. A precedent does not require a defendant who is still locatable.

Standing and note on visiting

Brae holds no rank in any surviving roll. Her appearance in the archive is that of a name attached to a consequence, which is the most common form of immortality available to scribes of the middle scriptoria. Copies of Annex 11 are held on Floors 718 and 907, both of which may be visited by appointment; visitors to Floor 907 are reminded that the ledger on that floor is not to be closed, opened, or acknowledged.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Pre-Dawn Evacuation of Y203 SCE: what happened?

The Pre-Dawn Evacuation of Y203 SCE was the transfer of Sigma-class archival materials from the Central Pneumatic Stacks to the containment vaults of the Seventeenth Gallery, carried out in the dark hours of the 17th of …

Pre-Dawn Evacuation of Y203 SCE
Librarian-Taxonomist's Office: who are they?

The Librarian-Taxonomist's Office is the administrative body of the Librarian-Taxonomist cadre, the order of certified readers empowered to classify holdings exhibiting advanced systemic instability. It was formally inst…

Librarian-Taxonomist's Office
Archival Evacuation: how is it conducted?

Archival Evacuation is the removal of holdings from a floor, stack, vault, or corridor under conditions that the duty archivist judges cannot be waited out. It is distinguished from Archival Relocation, which is schedule…

Archival Evacuation
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.