The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Office of the Chief Harmonist

MS 1938.97 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Office of the Chief Harmonist is the coordinating body responsible for the alignment of inspection and audit schedules across the bureaus of the Directorate of Form and Symmetry. It does not conduct inspections. It does not issue findings. It determines when the bureaus of the Directorate may inspect, and in what order, and whether the order it has determined is to be regarded as binding. On this last question the Office has declined, since its founding, to rule.

The Office occupies the eastern gallery of the floor designated Floor 1,212 and is staffed by nine clerks, one of whom is always the Harmonist. The remaining eight are referred to, collectively and in correspondence, as the Attendant Cadence. Requests for an inspection window are submitted on Form H-3; requests to have a Form H-3 rescheduled are submitted on Form H-3 with a second line drawn beneath the date. Clerks are permitted to use an eraser. Pencil is required throughout the Office, at every grade of seniority, in all matters touching schedule.

Origins and the Schedules of 4 Delta

The Office was constituted by the Concordance of Interlocking Duties, Annex 9, following the confusion of 4 Delta, in which three bureaus of the Directorate — Measurement, Ornamentation, and Pending Corrections — arrived at the same vault on the same afternoon to audit the same plinth and discovered that none of them had been appointed to do so. The resulting inquiry found that every bureau had been acting on a valid instruction and that all three instructions could not simultaneously be obeyed. The Annex attributed the difficulty to what it called "the unscheduled adjacencies of honest offices."

The remedy was the Office. Its first Chief Harmonist, Odile Marrow (eighth holder of that title is the current one; Marrow was the first), established the doctrine of the holding window: no audit begins until the preceding audit has been formally concluded, and no conclusion is formally registered until the Harmonist has heard it read aloud. Reading aloud takes approximately forty minutes and is not considered part of the audit. A proposal to consider it part of the audit was tabled in 117 and remains tabled.

Relationship to the Harmonist Lyr Vorn

The title of Harmonist is older than the Office that now bears it, and the Office has spent considerable energy distinguishing itself from Harmonist Lyr Vorn, first Director of the Bureau of Quantitative Esoteria and originator of the Vorn Criterion. The distinction is jurisdictional rather than personal. Vorn's criterion measures whether a quantity is measurable; the Office measures whether a measurement may begin. The two are frequently confused by junior clerks, and the Office of the Chief Sequencer has twice issued a Sequencers Determination correcting the confusion without, in the view of this Office, correcting it.

The Office's position is set out in its standing circular of 209: "A thing may be measurable and inadvisable to measure on a Thursday. The Office is concerned with the Thursday." (Office of the Chief Harmonist, Standing Circular 209, para. 2)

Procedure and the Cadence Ledger

All scheduled audits are entered in the Cadence Ledger, a bound volume of some eleven thousand folios maintained continuously since the Office's founding. The Ledger records, for each audit, the bureau, the floor, the window, and the name of the auditor who did not attend. This last column was added in 143 after the Attendant Cadence observed that absences were being recorded inconsistently and that the record of an audit was, in practice, a record of who was not there.

"The Ledger shall be kept in ink. Corrections shall be kept in ink of a different colour. The clerk keeping the Ledger shall not be the clerk who reads it aloud, unless the Ledger is short."

— Concordance of Interlocking Duties, Annex 9, clause 14

The Clerk of the Ledger during the winter of 188, Perrin Halloway, raised the grievance that has since become the standard complaint of the Office: that he had been asked to keep the Ledger, to read it, and to be short. Halloway's grievance was heard by the Office of the Chief Librarian and dismissed on the ground that the Office of the Chief Harmonist is not a party to whom the OCL's regulatory powers extend, the Office having no archive of its own beyond the Ledger. The Ledger, the OCL noted, is a schedule and not a record, notwithstanding that it is the only surviving record of several audits.

Dispute with the Office of the Chief Archivist

The question of whether the Cadence Ledger is a record has been the subject of an unresolved disagreement between this Office and the Office of the Chief Archivist since at least 152, when the Archivist's examiners sought to take a recension of the Ledger for the Register of Chief Archivists. The Harmonist of the day, Vess Ardent (fourth holder), refused the recension on the ground that a recension of a schedule would freeze the schedule at a moment when the schedule had not yet agreed with itself.

The Office of the Chief Archivist has never accepted this. Its position, restated in a memorandum of 203, is that a document that is consulted in order to establish what happened is a record regardless of what its keeper calls it, and that the Office of the Chief Harmonist is therefore an archival body that has declined to be archived. The Chamber of Verified Function, which reports directly to the Office of the Chief Archivist, has been asked to rule on the matter and has not.

Contradiction in the Concordances

Scholars disagree on whether the Office may refuse to schedule an audit at all — that is, whether the holding window doctrine implies a power of indefinite deferral. The Third Concordance, Annex 4, holds that "no office shall be kept waiting beyond the convenience of the Harmonist," which plainly grants the power. The Concordance of Interlocking Duties, Annex 9, clause 6, holds with equal plainness that "every audit submitted shall be scheduled, and the Harmonist shall not be the judge of the submission." Both are in force. The Office has resolved the contradiction administratively: it schedules every submission and dates it to the last window of the current spiral, which is to say, not yet.

It is customary for a visiting examiner to present themselves at the eastern gallery before the ninth bell and to leave their seal with the Attendant Cadence, who will return it at the conclusion of the visit or at the end of the day, whichever is later.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of the Chief Archivist: who are they?

The Office of the Chief Archivist (OCA) is the principal administrative and archival body responsible for the maintenance, verification, and canonical organization of the Tower's corpus of holdings. It holds primary arch…

Office of the Chief Archivist
Bureau of Quantitative Esoteria: who are they?

“To know the names of things is a pleasure. To know their numbers is the only truth.”

Bureau of Quantitative Esoteria
Office of the Chief Librarian: who are they?

The Office of the Chief Librarian (abbreviated OCL) is the central executive and administrative organ of the Librarianate, responsible for the promulgation of Concordances, the authorization of major expeditions, and the…

Office of the Chief Librarian
Directorate of Form and Symmetry: who are they?

Directorate of Form and Symmetry is a regulatory body operating under the Directorate of Archival Coherence, charged with enforcing structural and representational standards for catalogued subjects across the Tower. Its …

Directorate of Form and Symmetry

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.