The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Interpretive Synod

MS 5315.11 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Interpretive Synod is a standing convocation of the Tower charged with resolving mutually incompatible interpretations of the Concordances when such incompatibility has been formally certified as a state of Procedural Incongruence. It is distinct from the Curatorial Synod, which legislates on catalogical principle, and from the Interpretive Panels, which convene An Interpretive Session in the ordinary course and issue Interpretive Rulings where the doctrine of Least Interpretive Interpolation is in dispute. The Interpretive Synod convenes only where the Panels cannot proceed — where two or more readings, each internally sound, cannot both hold and neither can be retired. Its seat is the ninth gallery of the Concordance Synod complex, though it has not sat there since the winter of the Long Recension, when the heating failed on galleries seven through eleven and the convocation was moved to a reading room on floor 2211 adjacent to the Dusty Corners stacks.

Origins and charter

The Synod's charter derives, like that of the Archivists' Synod, from the residual clauses of the Synod of the Quill — specifically the fourth residual clause, which reserved to the order the interpretation of any document it had itself drafted and later abandoned. When the functions of the Quill were absorbed by the Synod of Dusty Corners and the Synod of Minor Archivists, the interpretive residual passed first to the Synod of Precise Meaning, which held it for eleven years and attempted to exercise it exactly once. The attempt is recorded as The Eleven-Year Silence and is not discussed at length. The charter as presently recited makes no claim to interpret truth, only to select among interpretations. A frequently cited formulation, attributed to the recension clerk Librarian-Archivist Ypsilon, holds that the Synod "does not say what a Concordance means, but which meaning the Tower will be governed by until it means something else" (Dissenting Opinion of Librarian-Archivist Ypsilon, marginal note 3). Ypsilon later disowned the phrasing as "too clear."

Procedure for convening

A state of Procedural Incongruence is declared by the Office of Procedural Incongruence upon receipt of two certified readings that cannot be reconciled. The declaration must be sealed, countersigned, and delivered to the Synod's registrar within one hundred days. The Synod is then convened by writ. It must reach a determination within a single sitting, a constraint inherited from the Quill and never relaxed, despite at least forty petitions to extend it. Because the sitting may not be adjourned, the Synod is convened only when a quorum of readings has been assembled in advance: opposing readings, concordant readings, and the reading of the Third Synod on Provenance, which is entered into the record as a matter of course whether or not it bears on the question. Delegates from the Synod of Marginalia attend and do not vote.

Interpreted Concordance 410.2 Annex α

The Synod's most consequential determination remains its reading of Interpreted Concordance 410.2 Annex α, which it held to grant nothing at all. The holding was reached after a sitting of some nineteen hours, in the course of which the Annex was read aloud four times and compared against three earlier recensions of itself. The Synod's conclusion — that the Annex confers no authority, creates no office, and disposes of no property — was received without recorded dissent. The practical difficulty is that a great many floors were catalogued under the impression that the Annex did something. The holding did not unsettle those catalogues, because the Synod's determinations govern interpretation and not possession. Floors continued to cite the Annex in their own accessions for a further thirty years. Whether the Synod's holding or the floors' practice is to be preferred is a question referred repeatedly to the Curatorial Synod and never resolved. One floor, whose number appears in the record as 611, retains a reading room furnished entirely under the Annex and refuses to furnish any other way.

Relationship to the Curatorial Synod

The two bodies overlap in jurisdiction and disagree about the overlap. The Curatorial Synod has asserted, in the seventy-second article of the proceedings of the 712th Synod, that interpretation of a Concordance is a species of catalogical principle and therefore falls to it. The Interpretive Synod has answered that procedurally incongruent readings are not principles but emergencies, and that emergencies are its own. Both positions have been printed in the same volume with a note that the contradiction is "standing." The Archivists' Synod has declined to arbitrate, noting only that its charter derives from the same residual clauses and that it would prefer not to be asked. Delegates from the Seventh Synod of Scribes were once invited to observe and spent the sitting correcting the minutes.

Criticism and the standing dissent

The most persistent criticism is that a body which selects among meanings without deciding meaning accumulates determinations that later determinations must themselves be interpreted, and so forth. Librarian-Archivist Ypsilon pressed this point for six sittings and it has since been called the accretion objection. The Synod does not answer the objection in its rulings. A private note preserved in its register, unsigned but in a clerical hand, concedes the difficulty and observes that "the alternative is to let two readings stand, which the Tower has tried, on floor 881, and the floor has not been the same." The Synod's sittings are held on the second day of the working week. Visitors are admitted to the gallery, are asked to remain silent, and are asked not to lean on the railing, which is original.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

An Interpretive Session: how is it conducted?

An Interpretive Session is the convened sitting at which an Interpretive Panel receives questions of textual ambiguity conveyed to it by the Interpretive Stream and issues Interpretive Rulings in reply. Sessions are held…

An Interpretive Session
Third Synod on Provenance: what happened?

The Third Synod on Provenance was a convocation of the Provenance assembly, held over nine sessions in the winter of the 604th Synod, at which the reforms of Provenance Master Kael were adopted by a margin of four votes.…

Third Synod on Provenance
Archivists' Synod: who are they?

Archivists' Synod is the colloquial and partly deprecated designation for the standing convocation of Grade 7 (Provisional) Archivists convened under Third Concordance to deliberate matters of minor cataloguing dispute, …

Archivists' Synod
the Concordances: what does it set out?

The Concordances constitute the legal and administrative framework governing the operations, authority, and internal disputes of The Tower. They are a living corpus of documents, perpetually amended and expanded by The L…

the Concordances

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.