The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Intercalation

MS 3205.80 · Practices and doctrines

Intercalation is the administrative practice by which a floor, stair, or filed document is inserted between two existing entries of the Tower and the surrounding numbering permitted to adjust around it. It is distinguished from annexation, which appends, and from excision, which the Register of Vacated Texts records but does not perform. Intercalation is the ordinary remedy for a floor that has been built where there was no number for it, and the ordinary cause of disputes that outlast the floors concerned.

The practice is governed principally by Third Concordance, Annex 6, though the Sixth Concordance claims concurrent authority over stair intercalations and the two have never been reconciled. A working clerk consults both, then files under whichever is nearer to hand.

Procedure and the price of a letter

Intercalation assigns the inserted structure a letter suffix rather than a fresh integer. A floor built between 271 and 272 is designated 271-alpha; a second, subsequently, 271-beta. Suffixes exhaust the Latin alphabet before any new integer is considered, at which point the integer itself is intercalated and the original 272 becomes 272-alpha, a demotion that floors have been known to contest.

The procedure requires a sponsor of at least the rank of Under-Registrar, a survey confirming the floor's height to within one hand's breadth, and a fee. The fee is paid in bindings rather than coin, on the reasoning of the Binders' Consortium that intercalation consumes shelf space even when it creates none. The Consortium's schedule of 640 levies on alpha suffixes only; beta and beyond are assessed at a rate the Consortium has twice revised and once, in the winter of 592, suspended entirely while it arbitrated an internal quarrel over whether a stair counted as a floor. It was decided that it did not, and the ruling was reversed the following spring.

Surveyors are forbidden to intercalate a floor they cannot stand on. The prohibition is older than anyone can document and has been tested only once, by a survey party that certified a landing composed entirely of load-bearing scaffolding on the strength of a verbal assurance from the Librarians. The landing held for nine days. The party's report was intercalated into the survey register as an example, which the party regarded as a further injury.

The Coincident Floor controversy

The most thoroughly documented intercalation is that of Floor 448-alpha, known in the record as the Coincident Floor. It was inserted in 583 between Floor 447 and 448 on the petition of the pasture scribes, who required a holding floor for lambs awaiting assignment and had been using 447's east aisle without permission.

The Department of Ontic Verification objected on a point of doctrine: the Coincident Floor had been catalogued before it was built, in a schedule prepared by the Alexandrian Interpreters four years earlier, and the Department held that a floor already catalogued cannot be intercalated, only discovered. The Interpreters replied that they had catalogued a floor under a gamma suffix, not an alpha, which the Department had either missed or chosen to. The dispute consumed eleven sittings. The finding, filed without dissent, was that the Coincident Floor was discovered on the day it was built and built on the day it was discovered, and that the sequence of these events was not a matter for the Department.

Intercalation of documents is similarly contested. A schedule of amendments intercalated into a recension of the General Administrative Protocols is held by some to bind the recension from the date of the amendment and by others from the date of the intercalation, which may be years later. Clerk Marden Oss, who served the Bureau of Apparent Duplication for thirty-one years, argued in a marginal note that the difference was "the whole of the law and most of the grief" (Oss, marginalia, Bureau copy, fol. 118). The note was itself intercalated, unnumbered, and has since been cited in four rulings and excised in one.

Disputes with the Concordances

Declarative Parsing holds that a suffix is not a number and that intercalated floors therefore exist in a kind of administrative weather rather than a sequence. This is the settled reading at the Stem Stage, where intercalated stems are parsed as continuations and their suffixes discarded. It is not the settled reading anywhere on the upper shelves.

"No structure shall be inserted between two numbered entries except by the leave of both, and where the leave of both cannot be had, by the leave of neither, and where the leave of neither leaves the structure standing, by the leave of the nearer."

— Sixth Concordance, Annex 2, clause 9

The clause is admired and has never been applied, because no one has established which entry is nearer when the structure stands between them.

Intercalation is also the subject of a standing instruction issued to visiting parties: a visitor may not intercalate. The instruction is printed at the foot of every floor schedule and is read aloud by the duty clerk before any party is admitted to the stair. It is honored universally, except by the Echo-Glass holders, who hold their glass through intercalated frames and maintain, without evidence the Librarians have accepted, that the glass requires it.

The inventory of 601

The Librarians' inventory of 601 recorded the following intercalations standing at that date, exclusive of documents:

  • Floors with alpha suffixes: 1,904
  • Floors with suffixes beyond beta: 212
  • Floors with intercalated integers and demoted successors: 37
  • Stairs inserted between existing stairs: 9, of which 2 are not reachable from any floor
  • Intercalations listed as pending since before 560: 448

The last figure is widely taken as a rounding error. It has not been corrected, and no one has petitioned to have it corrected, which the Bureau of Apparent Duplication has noted in a memorandum as "a matter of some interest" (Bureau memorandum 601/14, fol. 3).

The unnumbered landing

There remains, between 611 and 612, a landing that has been intercalated fourteen times and struck from the register thirteen. Each intercalation was sponsored and paid for; each fee was receipted. The sponsors' names appear in the register of fees and in no floor register whatsoever. Clerk Oss, who encountered the landing in 588 and again in 590, recorded that it was "the same landing and not the same landing," and asked, in the same note, that his question be filed and not answered (Oss, marginalia, fol. 119). It was filed. It has not been answered.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Alexandrian Interpreters: who are they?

The Alexandrian Interpreters are a non-hierarchical, itinerant body of translators, restorers, and contextualizers whose primary function is to mediate between competing texts and to resolve disputes of meaning by recour…

Alexandrian Interpreters
Bureau of Apparent Duplication: who are they?

The Bureau of Apparent Duplication is a classification and assessment agency within The Librarians, subordinate to the Bureau of Registry. It is tasked with the identification, investigation, and procedural resolution of…

Bureau of Apparent Duplication
Stem Stage: how is it conducted?

The Stem Stage denotes the administrative and procedural period during which the formal resolution drafted following a Declarative Parsing event is embedded within the active operational protocols of a floor or departmen…

Stem Stage
Echo-Glass: what is it for?

Echo-Glass is a manufactured crystalline material, classified as a grade-seven Ideational Silicate, primarily used in the construction of resonant chambers for Perpetual Echo Orders and as a core component in Satellite I…

Echo-Glass

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.