The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Intentional Inscription

MS 4479.64 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and Scope

Intentional Inscription is the class of mark, cut, or applied character admitted to the catalogical record on the ground that its maker intended it to be read. The definition derives from the Sixth Concordance, which reserves catalogical scope to intentional inscription and thereby excludes from the record all incidental marking — wear, spill, the scoring left by dragged furniture, and the accidental impressions of boots. Where an inscription's intent cannot be established, it is held in the intermediate category of Secondary Inscription pending review; where intent is established but the mark has since faded below the threshold fixed at the Bureau of Intentional Measurement, it passes to the register of Intentional Erosion.

Intentional Inscription is distinguished from Scribal Inscription in that the latter names the office and its hand, while the former names the condition of admissibility. An inscription may be scribal and unintentional (a pen-testing flourish in a margin) or non-scribal and entirely intentional (a notch cut by a porter to count crates). Only the second of these is catalogued as Intentional Inscription proper.

The Question of the Notch

The doctrine's hardest surviving case is the dispute over the counting-notches of the Lower Freight Stair, Floor 1,144, cut across the winter of the year recorded as 2 Alpha. The notches were made by a porter identified in the ledger only as Halven of the Ninth Landing, who cut one notch per crate and stated, when examined, that he had done so "that I might know how many there were, and not be told again by someone who was not there" (Deposition of Halven, Annex 2, clause 7).

The Bureau of Intentional Measurement ruled the notches incidental on the ground that the porter intended an accounting, not a text. The ruling was overturned on appeal by the argument — advanced by the surveyor Coris of the Freight Register — that the porter had further intended the notches to be read by himself, at a later date, which is a reader. The Sixth Concordance has never been amended to settle which reasoning governs, and both are cited in the current register.

"A mark intended for any reader at any future time is an inscription; the identity, reluctance, or eventual absence of that reader is not a matter for the Bureau."

— Fourth Concordance, Annex 9

Relation to Intentional Redundancy

Intentional Inscription is frequently found in the maintenance of Intentional Scaffolding records, where an inscription must be legible at two distances and is therefore cut twice. The practice is an inheritance from the doctrine of Intentional Redundancy credited to Aris of Intentional Design, whose earliest surviving articulation holds that a record meant to survive its own space must be inscribed more than once and in more than one place. The Lyceum of Intentional Design ratified the application of this doctrine to inscriptions during the Intentional Cross-Examination of the year 3 Gamma, over the objection of the School of Intentional Architecture, which maintained that duplication adulterated the original hand.

The Lyceum's position prevailed by a margin of two voices, and the dissent was entered verbatim into the record. It remains there, unamended, and is read aloud at the opening of each subsequent Cross-Examination.

Inscription and the Unbounded Space

Because Intentional Scaffolding must be standing for an echo to be reliably produced as Intentional, any inscription made within an Unbounded Intentional Space before its ratification is regarded as provisional and is not entered in the main register. Provisional entries are kept on slips in the Slip Annex and are not bound. Roughly one slip in nine is later found to have been bound anyway.

Governance and Amendment

Intentional Inscription is administered under the Third Concordance, whose clause on the admissibility of multiple hands is the most-amended clause in the corpus, having been revised eleven times between the years 4 Gamma and 6 Delta. The clause as currently read permits any number of hands provided each is separately attested; the reading preferred by the Bureau of Intentional Measurement, and disputed by the Lyceum of Intentional Design, requires that the hands be attested in the order they appear. No case has yet turned on the difference, though two are pending.

A standing prohibition applies to the use of the outer stairwells for practice inscription. The prohibition was issued after the winter of 5 Beta, when a clerk of the Office of Sealed Annexes — named in the complaint as Murelle of the Sixth Seal — practised her hand on the risers of the Floor 2,203 landing and produced a surface that could not subsequently be classified as either intentional or incidental without the removal of the stair. The stair was not removed. The landing is closed.

Inventory of Standing Classes

The following classes are presently admitted to the register, each with its own attestation seal:

  • Cut inscription, attested by the cutting tool and the hand.
  • Applied inscription, attested by the medium and the hand.
  • Repeated inscription, attested under the doctrine of Intentional Redundancy.

Classes are added only by Cross-Examination and removed only by Librarian's Prerogative, a remedy invoked four times in the last century and regretted on three of those occasions.

Disputed Readings

The principal disagreement among the Tower's commentators concerns whether intent is a property of the maker or of the mark. The Sixth Concordance locates intent in the maker and the Fourth Concordance locates it in the mark's fitness to be read — a contradiction noted in the Concordance Marginalia and left standing. The Bureau of Intentional Measurement has adopted the maker's intent for purposes of measurement and the mark's fitness for purposes of retention, permitting an inscription to be simultaneously unintentional and retained. Neither Concordance forbids this, and neither anticipates it.

The Lyceum of Intentional Design has declared a period of Intentional Ontic Instability with respect to the question and has asked that all disputed inscriptions be left in place until the period closes. The period has not closed.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Intentional Ontic Instability: how is it conducted?

Intentional Ontic Instability is a formal practice within the Tower's custodial framework, defined as the deliberate and circumscribed suspension of conventional material coherence to facilitate inquiry into subjects tha…

Intentional Ontic Instability
School of Intentional Architecture: who are they?

The School of Intentional Architecture is a formal discipline and architectural guild dedicated to the principled design, classification, and management of structures and spaces defined by their underlying intent rather …

School of Intentional Architecture
Unbounded Intentional Space: how is it conducted?

Unbounded Intentional Space denotes a specialized domain of architectural design and ontological potential where the primary constraints of physical dimension, structural fatigue, and categorical containment are supersed…

Unbounded Intentional Space
Intentional Redundancy: how is it conducted?

Intentional Redundancy is the deliberate duplication of a catalogued item, entry, or filing across two or more locations within the Tower, performed with the explicit knowledge that the copies will not agree. It is disti…

Intentional Redundancy

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.