The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Hargrove Longitudinal Study of Decaying Protocols

MS 4556.66 · Practices and doctrines

The Hargrove Longitudinal Study of Decaying Protocols is a continuing observational programme of the Dissonance Registry, commenced in the year of the fourth recension (registry date 4.0.1) and not yet concluded. Its subject is the rate at which Protocols cease to govern: the point at which a protocol remains in force, is still cited in disputes, and is nevertheless no longer observed by anyone. The Study calls this the protocol's operative decay, and reports it quarterly in Tables 1 through 9, of which Table 5 has been under revision since the second year.

The Study is housed on Floor 18 and borrows its name from the Hargrove Scale, though the two instruments measure different quantities and are frequently confused by clerks newly assigned to the Registry. The Scale measures ambient atmospheric Dissonance; the Study measures the lapse of procedural authority. That the same shadow of 3.1 Ld falls across the Study's instrument table each afternoon is regarded by the Registry as coincidence and by the Study's opponents as evidence of the reverse.

Method

Each protocol selected for observation is entered in the Study's roll and thereafter examined at intervals of one hundred days. Observers record three readings: whether the protocol is still cited in live disputes, whether it is still performed in the floors where it originated, and whether its text has been amended without being read. A protocol that is cited but not performed is classed residual; one that is performed but no longer cited is classed habitual; one that is neither is classed decayed and is transferred, with full honours, to the Gallery of Unanswered Questions.

The Study has never succeeded in observing a protocol amend itself, though it has twice observed a protocol amended by a clerk who had not read it, which the Registry treats as the same event at one remove.

Findings

The first sustained result of the Study is that protocols decay fastest when most often quoted. A protocol cited daily in argument is performed roughly half as often as one cited never, a finding the Study's second report states without comment and which the Registry has since declined to discuss. The report's summary table records the following landmarks of the current roll:

  • Protocol 44-B (Retention of Blanched Subjects): residual after 2,300 days; now administered wholly under Division II, Taxonomic Recursions.
  • Protocol 61-K (Airing of the Seventh Helical Gallery): habitual; performed each morning by a caretaker who has not read it.
  • Protocol 9-D (Illumination of the Chamber of Fading Light): residual; the sconces of Decaying Lumenium are logged hourly against a master standard by staff who cite the protocol only when challenged.
  • Protocol 17 (Emergency Retention of Sound): decayed; transferred to the Gallery in the ninth year, where it is reported to be thriving.

The Orrin Marginalia Dispute

The Study's most contested finding concerns the marginalia of the archivist Vell Orrin, who annotated the Study's first roll with observations on protocols he believed had already lapsed. Orrin's notes were struck from the record by the Hargrove Loop, on the ground that a closed administrative circuit cannot receive marginal annotation from outside itself. The Study, lacking any authority to reinstate them, has since cited the struck notes obliquely, in footnotes that refer to "certain observations of the first roll, no longer available."

The Hargrove Memorandum later took the Loop to task for this, arguing that the Study had preferred the tidy circuit to the untidy observation, and that this preference was itself a measurable decay. The Memorandum's author is not named in its text, and the Registry has not asked.

Conflict with the Standardized Scales

A standing disagreement divides the Study from the keepers of the Standardized Dissonance Scale, who maintain that operative decay is a species of Dissonance and ought to be reported on their scale rather than the Study's. The Study has replied, in its fourth report, that a protocol does not emit anything and cannot therefore be measured at a distance. The keepers of the Standardized Scale respond that neither does Dissonance, which the Study has not answered.

"The beam does not care what it is pointed at. It is the pointing that requires a protocol, and the protocol that points the beam is the first to decay."

— Ordinance of Perilous Ambience, Annex 2, gloss on measurement

Related work on protocols that govern impermanent subjects is carried out under Protocols for Impermanent Media, whose observers the Study lends its tables in alternate years. The arrangement is informal and has never been written down, which the Registry considers prudent.

Current Status

The Study's roll presently carries 1,208 protocols, of which 411 are residual, 596 habitual, and 201 decayed. Table 5 remains under revision. Observers are reminded that the Study's instrument table must not be dusted during readings, that the north door is to be left ajar for the caretaker of Floor 7,113, and that any protocol discovered to have decayed during the observer's own reading of it should be reported before the reading is completed, not after.

No end date for the Study has been proposed. The Registry's position, stated in a minute of the seventh year and reaffirmed at each subsequent recension, is that a longitudinal study of decay cannot conclude without producing the finding it was convened to observe.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Hargrove Loop: how is it conducted?

The Hargrove Loop is a closed administrative circuit of the Dissonance Registry, named for the instrument whose readings it was devised to reconcile. It is not a mapped loop in the sense administered by the Scribes of th…

Hargrove Loop
Protocols: how is it conducted?

Protocols in the Tower refer to a codified system of procedures and regulations that govern the operation, maintenance, and study of the archival structure and its holdings. The Registry of Protocols serves as the defini…

Protocols
Hargrove Scale: what is it for?

The Hargrove Scale is a graduated beam instrument for the measurement of ambient atmospheric Dissonance, installed on Floor 18 in the winter of the year recorded as 3,104 by the Calendar of Sealed Recensions. It is the o…

Hargrove Scale
Standardized Dissonance Scale: how is it conducted?

The Standardized Dissonance Scale is the Tower's principal instrument of documentary comparison, a graduated notation by which readings of Documentary Dissonance are expressed in units called Docons. Unlike the beam inst…

Standardized Dissonance Scale

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.