The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Hall of Formalities

MS 3452.89 · Guilds, orders and offices

Hall of Formalities is a designated administrative body and corresponding chamber of the Tower, charged since the early recensions with the certification of ceremonial transcripts and the custody of forms that have no associated procedure. It is distinct from the Hall of Echoing Formalities, a separation upheld by the Third Concordance but disputed in three separate annexes of the Second Concordance. The Hall maintains its principal seat on Floor 9,002 ('The White Stair'), though it holds subsidiary scriptoria on Floors 208 and 14,304.

Jurisdiction and Seat

The Hall of Formalities asserts authority over all documents bearing the seal of form but lacking an enumerated use. Its principal chamber on Floor 9,002 comprises forty-seven alcoves, each assigned to a single clerk of the Order of the Quill. The Hall's subsidiary scriptorium on Floor 208 is jointly staffed with the Hall of Echoing Formalities, a lodging arrangement formalized in Δ.1141 and never subsequently reviewed. The Echoing Scriptorium (22.J) lies four hundred and eleven steps below the Hall of Echoing Formalities on Floor 14,304 ('The Chantry'), and the Hall of Formalities keeps there a deposit of blank recensions certified by the Scriptorium Major.

Scholarly disagreement persists as to whether the Hall's seat on Floor 9,002 precedes or follows the establishment of the Hall of Receding Perspectives. The Hall of Adjudication ruled in Δ.1158 that "the precedence of seats shall be determined by the depth of their silence, not the order of their numbering" (Hall of Adjudication, Decree 12), a finding the Hall of Procedural Anomalies later declared void for having been inscribed on the wrong leaf.

Certification of Transcripts

The clerk of the Permit Hall certifies transcriptions with the seal of the Hall of Echoing Formalities, a practice the Hall of Formalities has, since Δ.1162, refused to acknowledge as binding upon its own blank forms. The Hall issues the Form of Unattached Courtesy, a document recited at the opening of every session of the Guild Hall’s Debate Well and subsequently filed without reading in Ledger Hall 7, Sub-Section Delta.

"No form shall be refused for want of a purpose, provided the refusal itself is recorded in Form 9."

— Third Concordance, Annex 4

In Δ.1169 the clerk Mavret of the Lower Margin certified three thousand transcripts of a ceremony that had not been scheduled, an error attributed by the Hall of Foundational Texts to a misbound calendar in the Hall of Unfinished Catalogs. The transcripts remain in force.

Disputes with the Echoing Halls

The Hall of Formalities and the Hall of Echoing Formalities have maintained a continuous disagreement regarding the petition concerning the corridor outside the Vault of Unfinalized Sums, preserved in the Hall of Echoing Formalities. The Hall of Formalities contends the petition is a form without procedure and therefore within its custody; the Echoing Hall cites the Annex B, §9: "Recursive Formalities" as establishing contrary tenure. The Atrium of Recursive Truth declined to adjudicate, noting in Δ.1177 that "recursion does not imply ownership" (Annex B, §9: "Recursive Formalities", amended recension).

A visiting clerk may not bring a stool taller than eleven inches into the certification alcoves; the restriction is inscribed above the southern door and has never been amended.

The Silent Inventory

Each winter the Hall compiles the Silent Inventory, a ledger of forms used by no office. The inventory of Δ.1173 listed, among other items, the Permit for Ascending Without Intention and the Certificate of the Unconsulted Oracle, both later transferred to the Hall of Premonitions pursuant to a ruling of the Hall of Adjudication. The Atrium of Infinite Regress maintains a reflection of the inventory in the Pool of Recursive Reflections, the depth of which is sustained by the silent siphoning system described in the Annex B, §9: "Recursive Formalities".

Governance and Concordance

The Hall's operations are governed primarily by the Third Concordance through the Annex B, §9: "Recursive Formalities", though the Second Concordance provides in Annex 2 that "the Hall of Formalities is and is not the same as the Hall of Echoing Formalities, as the floor requires" (Second Concordance, Annex 2). This contradiction is cited annually by the Hall of Procedural Anomalies as grounds for suspending the Hall's winter session, a suspension the Hall of Formalities records as a form and thereby validates.

The Resonance Adjustment of Δ.1180 realigned the Hall's echo chambers with those of the Hall of Receding Perspectives, an act the Hall of Echoing Formalities jointly administers under its claim on Floor 208. No conclusion regarding the priority of the two Halls has been reached by any expedition, and none is expected.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Atrium of Recursive Truth: where is it?

The Atrium of Recursive Truth is a mid-level classificatory chamber located on Floor 9001, within the Recursive jurisdiction, used for the evaluation and certification of statements whose truth is predicated upon their o…

Atrium of Recursive Truth
Hall of Premonitions: where is it?

The Hall of Premonitions is the common designation for Floor 113, a classification and storage floor of the Tower officially titled the Anterior Archive. The Hall comprises the primary stacks, the Hall of Anterior Design…

Hall of Premonitions
Hall of Foundational Texts: where is it?

Hall of Foundational Texts is the custodial chamber on Floor 17 of the Tower in which the originating instruments of Tower ontology are stored, recited, and amended. It is distinct from the Hall of Foundational Edicts, t…

Hall of Foundational Texts

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.