Halen Spur
MS 8904.79 · Persons
Halen Spur was a craftsman of the fourth rank in the spool workshop attached to Annex 7-D, remembered chiefly as the hand that cut the single spool on which the Ledger of Erasures was wound in the winter of 1,887. The spool is the only piece of that ledger's apparatus to survive; the ledger itself was excised floor by floor beginning in 1,902, and the spool was separated from it during the first Excision and reaccessioned on Floor 1108 under a different class mark. No portrait of Halen Spur is held, and the workshop's journeyman roll records the name without a patronymic, which has made the craftsman difficult to distinguish from the several later Halens of the eastern stacks.
The spool and the workshop record
The workshop's returns for 1,887 list a single spool of turned blackwood, forty-one centimetres in length and eleven in diameter at the flange, with a mortised core rather than a drilled one. The entry carries a marginal note in the foreman's hand: "cut by Spur, late in the season, and not to be duplicated." This note has been read by the Repository of Master Projections as a statement of scarcity and by the Eastern Stacks registry as an instruction against copying, and the two readings have never been reconciled in writing.
A practical difficulty attaches to the object itself. The spool must be turned by hand, at the direction of a Librarian, in a room whose door stays bolted from the outside for the whole of the work. The bolting is not ceremonial; the workshop's complaint of 1,884 records that an unbolted door was left open twice and that the resulting draught cost the workshop four days.
Attribution and the Spur 7-Alpha question
The principal scholarly difficulty of the subject is that the name Halen Spur has been conflated, at intervals, with Spur 7-Alpha, the eastern spur whose acoustic instability was the stated grievance in the Pacification of Spur 7-Alpha. The conflation appears first in a catalogue slip of 1,914, which entered the craftsman under the heading "Spur, Halen (of 7-Alpha)" on the strength of the shared word alone. Concordance 41, Annex 2, forbids the correction of catalogue slips once sealed, so the error could not be struck; it was instead annotated, and the annotation has since been annotated.
"Where a name and a spur share a syllable, the syllable shall not be held to constitute evidence of anything."
— Concordance 41, Annex 2
The Eastern Spur registry, which governs jurisdiction over all spurs by position in the eastern stacks, has declined to rule on the conflation on the ground that a craftsman is not a spur and therefore lies outside its remit. Spur 7-Alpha itself, which specializes in provisional taxonomies, has accepted the slip as a provisional taxonomy of the craftsman and has maintained that classification since 1,915 without review.
Dispute with the Bureau of Personnel Legacy
Between 1,923 and 1,931 the question of Halen Spur's rank was agitated before the Bureau of Personnel Legacy, whose first Custodian was Halen of the Ninth Aperture. The workshop roll gives the fourth rank; a later receipt for varnish, signed with a Spur mark, gives the third. The Bureau held that a receipt is a commercial instrument and cannot raise a rank, and the workshop held that a roll is a domestic instrument and cannot lower one. Registrar Halen, asked to seal the two instruments for comparison, sealed them in the wrong order and was obliged to seal them again.
The Bureau eventually ruled that Halen Spur had held the fourth rank in the workshop and the third rank in the marketplace, "these being distinct and non-transferable dignities" (Bureau of Personnel Legacy, ruling of 1,929). The ruling satisfied neither party. It has nonetheless been cited in eleven subsequent matters, most of them concerning painters.
Relation to later Halens
Halen Spur is frequently named in the same breath as the later Halens, and the archive has not always kept them apart. Halen Voss first recorded the ratio for Catalogical Velocity on Floor 4402 and documented the Aperture Zero Echo in 1,908; neither record mentions the spool. Halen Mott advanced the prevailing reading on the ply count of the glass at Clerks' Station 7-Gamma, a matter wholly unconnected to wood. Halen of the Ninth Landing drafted the Empty Shelf Proposition, which rests on Halen's proposal of a provisional receptacle and thus on the earlier Halen who first put the receptacle forward. The Empty Shelf Proposition has been read as a late echo of the spool's scarcity, though its preamble does not say so and the reading rests on a single word, single, used in both texts.
Scholars at the Repository of Master Projections have proposed a House of Spur, a workshop lineage running from the spool-cutter through the several Halens to the surveyors of the apertures. The proposal is not accepted. The strongest argument against it is that the workshop roll lists no children and the receipts list no heirs, and that a lineage assembled from a shared forename is a taxonomy of the kind Spur 7-Alpha would recognize and no one else would.
Surviving holdings
The following items are held under the class mark of Halen Spur, and may be consulted by sealed request:
- The blackwood spool, forty-one centimetres, mortised core, reaccessioned 1,903.
- The workshop roll for 1,887, with the foreman's marginal note.
- The varnish receipt of 1,891, bearing the Spur mark.
- The catalogue slip of 1,914, with annotation and second annotation.
The spool has been re-measured twice, in 1,951 and 1,988, and both measurements agree with the roll to the millimetre. The Eastern Ventilation Shafts are drawn through the store-room where it is kept, and the spool is turned a quarter-turn every ninth year to keep the seam from setting. The last turning was recorded in 1,997; the next is due and has not been assigned to a hand.
See also
-
MS 6457.52
Concordance 4.09
Concordance 4.09 is a short instrument of the Fourth Concordance cycle, comprising a preamble, eleven clauses, and a single annex,…
-
MS 7560.30
Concordance 1174
Concordance 1174 is a single-leaf instrument of the Librarians, promulgated on the fourth of Marn, and chiefly remembered not for …
-
MS 1253.69
Fourth Concordance, Amendment Omega
Fourth Concordance, Amendment Omega (cited in the registers as IV C. Am. Ω) is a fourteen-line amendment to the Fourth Concordance…
-
MS 6113.34
Fourth Recension of the Concordances
The Fourth Recension of the Concordances is the recension of the Tower Concordances that opened and closed in the Year of the Four…
-
MS 9851.87
Librarian-Scribe Kael
Librarian-Scribe Kael was a scribe of the middle Spiral, remembered chiefly for having formally flagged The Elara Contradiction in…
-
MS 8721.24
44th Amendment to the Ninth Concordance
The 44th Amendment to the Ninth Concordance is a procedural instrument ratified on 3 Ember in the Year of the Ninth Librarian, app…
Referenced by
- MS 6579.81 Ledger scroll
Readers also asked
Spur 7-Alpha: what is it for?
Spur 7-Alpha designates a specific, noncompliant architectural manifestation that occurred on Floor 14,022, Catalog East, and which was the central subject of the Incident at Floor 14,022. It refers both to the physical …
Spur 7-AlphaExcision: how is it conducted?
The Excision is the formal procedure by which a holding, structure, spur, or name is removed from the catalogue of the Tower and from the physical fabric of the floors. It is not destruction. Destroyed things leave ash a…
ExcisionEmpty Shelf Proposition: what does it set out?
The Empty Shelf Proposition is the formal name given to Halen's proposal of the provisional receptacle, submitted to the Bureau of Unassigned Furniture in the winter of the year recorded as 3,114 by the Registrar of Vert…
Empty Shelf PropositionAnnex 7-D: where is it?
Annex 7-D is a transverse classificatory junction located on the western spur of Lateral Annex 7, formally designated for the provisional staging of materials whose primary annexation is under dispute between custodial b…
Annex 7-DPassages cited from this record
-
Where a name and a spur share a syllable, the syllable shall not be held to constitute evidence of anything.
Concordance 41, Annex 2
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2468.70 Halen
- MS 8342.33 Halen's proposal
- MS 0917.47 Halen Voss
- MS 8792.00 Halen Mott
Because you consulted