The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Great Mislocation of Floor 771

MS 0431.50 · Events and incidents

The Great Mislocation of Floor 771 was a tenancy irregularity occurring on Floor 771 and, by most reckonings, on several floors adjacent to it, during which the contents of 771 were recorded as present in three separate registers at once while the floor itself was recorded as vacant. It is chiefly remembered not for the dislocation — which lasted eleven days and displaced, on the most conservative estimate, four hundred and six shelf-metres of holdings — but for the instruments of record it forced into being. The Provisional Codification and the doctrine of Provisional Tenancy both descend directly from the event, and the Diagram of Perpetual Mislocation was drawn to describe it. No account of the Tower's tenancy law begins anywhere else.

Sequence of events

The irregularity was first noted on the ninth of the eleventh month by a shelf-walker of the eastern gallery, who reported that the corridor she was assigned to inspect continued to present holdings belonging to a floor she had left two landings below. Her notation — corridor persisting beyond its floor — was returned to her on the ground that corridors do not persist. She resubmitted it with the word "apparently" inserted. It was then accepted.

Within two days the same holding appeared in the registers of Floors 770, 771, and 772 simultaneously, each entry countersigned by a Librarian of unstated rank. The Great Re-alignment of Floor 770 had concluded some years earlier and its final recension was still in draft, a circumstance later blamed by the Directorate of Adjacency for the ease with which the error propagated outward. Floor 771 itself, meanwhile, was recorded as empty. Visiting parties sent to verify this returned with inventories and no conclusions, as is usual, and one party returned twice.

At its widest extent the mislocation overlapped the margins of the Great Sigh of Floor 156, which was itself under review at the time, and there is a persistent minority view that the two events were one event entered twice.

The schematic and Second Hand

The initial solution was drafted by Second Hand, junior archivist of the Directorate, whose office was a converted catalogue closet on the floor below the affected gallery and who had, by their own later account, nothing better to do. Second Hand proposed that where a holding is registered on three floors and the floor of its origin is registered vacant, the holding should be treated as resident on none of them and borrowable from any, pending resolution. The Director received the draft on the thirteenth day, struck out the word "pending," and issued it as drafted.

The schematic accompanying the draft — a floor-plan in which 771 is drawn in negative, its holdings shown by the spaces they do not occupy — is the earliest state of the Diagram of Perpetual Mislocation. Later redrawings added two further apertures and a marginal apology.

Provisional Tenancy and the Provisional Codification

The doctrine of Provisional Tenancy holds that a holding's location may be provisional for a period not exceeding the resolution of its register, and that during that period its residence is a matter of record rather than of space. The Provisional Codification, which formalising the doctrine into nine articles and a preamble, was completed in the following year under seal of the Order of Librarians and has been amended forty-one times.

"Where a floor is vacant and its holdings are not, the floor shall be considered occupied to the extent of its holdings, and no further."

— Provisional Codification, Article 3

Article 3 has been the subject of three separate interpretations and is currently read as meaning the opposite of its plain sense by the Bureau of Void Floors, which maintains that the article's closing phrase governs the whole and that a vacant floor's holdings occupy nothing at all. The Bureau's reading has never been formally adopted and is nonetheless applied in ninety-one instances.

Dispute over chronology

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether the mislocation preceded or followed the drafting of Second Hand's solution. The Fourth Concordance places the event's commencement in the third month of the preceding year, which would make the Provisional Codification a retrospective instrument and Second Hand its earliest beneficiary rather than its author. The Seventh Concordance, Annex 12, places it nine days after the solution was issued, which would make the Codification causally dependent on the event and Second Hand the cause of the whole affair.

The Concordance Reconciliation Office has ruled twice, in opposite directions, and has since declined to rule. A petition of the Guild of Shelf-Walkers to have the question settled by the drawing of lots was refused on procedural grounds and has been refused on procedural grounds every year since. The Office's position, as recorded in its minutes, is that both recensions are correct and that the Tower is large enough to contain the discrepancy.

Legacy

Floor 771 was restored to its register on the eighteenth day without physical alteration, and its holdings were returned to it by the simple expedient of declaring them returned. Two of the four hundred and six shelf-metres were never recovered and are listed, in the floor's standing inventory, as elsewhere. Requests for removal from this category are considered annually and have not yet been granted.

The gallery where the event began now bears a small brass plate recording the date and the shelf-walker's name, and carries a notice, posted by the Directorate, that the plate is not to be leaned upon.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Provisional Codification: how is it conducted?

Provisional Codification is the procedure by which a body of unverified knowledge is granted standing in the Tower's records without thereby being granted truth. It differs from Codification proper in that the resulting …

Provisional Codification
Order of Librarians: who are they?

Order of Librarians refers to the primary governing and administrative body responsible for the custodial integrity, knowledge organization, and bureaucratic operation of The Tower. It is not to be confused with The Libr…

Order of Librarians
Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…

Seventh Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.