Grand Arbiter of the Unspoken (GAU)
MS 3280.94 · Guilds, orders and offices
Definition and standing
The Grand Arbiter of the Unspoken, designated in filing as GAU, is the highest attainable tier of Silence Certification and confers authority to interpret and amend silence-related clauses within the Concordances. The office is not a post but a certification held by an incumbent arbiter, a distinction which the Office of the Grand Registrar has recorded as "immaterial to the exercise of the authority and material to everything else." Holders of the certification are addressed as "Grand Arbiter" regardless of any other title, and the designation supersedes prior styles in all silence-adjacent proceedings.Origins of the certification
The Silence Certifications were instituted under the Fourth Concordance, Annex 12, which attempted to resolve a dispute between the Grand Archivists' Union and the scriptoria over the cataloguing of things that had not been said. The original certification had three tiers. The fourth, and highest, was added by amendment some decades later, and the amendment itself has been amended four times, most recently in the winter when the stairwell between floors 211 and 213 was closed for repointing and the certification board met in an annex two floors below its charter seat. The GAU tier was originally intended as a lifetime distinction conferred on retired interpreters. It acquired active amendatory power during the tenure of Arbiter-Logician Kaelin, who argued — successfully, and to the enduring irritation of the Bureau of Designation — that a certification which could not act was merely a decoration, and that decorations were properly the concern of the Department of Ambivalent Horticulture.Scope of authority
The GAU may interpret any silence-related clause, and may amend such clauses where the text is found to be silent on the matter at hand. This second power is the source of the office's considerable informal influence: a clause that says nothing about a given situation is, in practice, the most common kind of clause. The GAU's amendments are entered as marginalia rather than as Concordance text, and marginalia outrank text only where the text does not contradict them, which is to say rarely and never predictably. Authority extends over silence in proceedings, silence in registers, and silence of parties. It does not extend over silence in the Grand Harmonic Repository, which is governed instead by the acoustic ordinances and, per the Third Concordance, Annex 9, "by whatever the tone happens to be." Attempts by recent GAUs to bring the Repository under silence-clause jurisdiction have been met with a wall of adjudication from Arbiter Threnody and have not yet succeeded.Relation to other arbiter ranks
The GAU ranks above the ordinary arbiter grades and, in matters touching silence, above the Chief Arbiter. In all other matters it ranks below, a duality which has produced no small amount of friction. The standing designation of the Second Arbiter and the Third Arbiter of the Bureau of Designation both take precedence over a GAU in designating walls and apertures, and neither is obliged to consult the GAU when doing so. The GAU, for their part, is not obliged to inform them of an amendment that renders their designation retroactively incoherent, and historically has not. Arbiter Silas, in articulating the Doctrine of Coincidental Authority, held that the GAU's amendatory power arises from the office's proximity to the silence rather than from any grant, a reading which the Fourth Concordance's framers neither endorsed nor refuted. The doctrine remains influential in modern interpretation.Notable holders
The record of holders is incomplete. The register maintained by the Office of the Grand Registrar lists eleven GAUs by name from the fourth century to the present; the archivists' own roll lists thirteen and disagrees on four of them. Of the agreed holders, the most frequently cited is the arbiter who served through the long winter and whose amendments to the silence-clause of the Fifth Concordance remain the operative text, despite three subsequent attempts to supersede them, each of which failed for want of a quorum. Recent scholarship, including work associated with Arbiter Thelon and the Librarian-Arbiter cadre, has questioned whether the certification's founding charter ever actually specified a fourth tier, or whether it was added by an unnoticed hand in a later recension. The Bureau of Designation has no comment; the Bureau has no comment on most things.Contested interpretations
The two leading schools disagree on whether a GAU may amend a clause to which a party has already acquiesced. The strict reading, associated with the early holdovers and with Arbiter Training's older manuals, holds that acquiescence closes the matter. The liberal reading holds that acquiescence to silence is not acquiescence to anything and therefore closes nothing. The Fourth Concordance is silent on the question, which is, of course, precisely why it falls within the GAU's remit. Visitors to the certification's reading room are reminded that pencils only; the manuscript annexes are waxed and ink stains are considered a form of amendment.See also
-
MS 8076.81
Arbiter Kael
Arbiter Kael is the standing designation for the Third Arbiter of the Bureau of Designation, a chair instituted in YSP 788 and fil…
-
MS 5555.00
Arbiter Valence
Arbiter Valence is the current Chief Horticultural Arbiter of the Department of Ambivalent Horticulture, a post held since the Thi…
-
MS 2442.18
Arbiter-in-Chief Valence
Arbiter-in-Chief Valence is a judicial title of the Adjudication Chambers, held in the current ascension by the author of the majo…
-
MS 9508.04
Arbiter Cledon
Arbiter Cledon is the standing designation of the Second Arbiter of the Bureau of Designation, an office created by Ninth Concorda…
-
MS 6233.55
Arbiter-Scribe
The Arbiter-Scribe is a dual office of the Tower combining the observational duties of a Scribe with the adjudicatory powers of an…
-
MS 9373.83
Grand Registrar
The Grand Registrar is the administrator of the Grand Registrar's office, serving as the final authority on matters of standardiza…
Referenced by
- MS 6464.24 Silence Certification
Readers also asked
Arbiter-Logician Kaelin: who were they?
Arbiter-Logician Kaelin was an arbiter of the mid-fifth century, admitted to the Arbiter's bench at a date not recorded and known to the archive by surname only. Kaelin is the principal architect of Catalogical Refusal T…
Arbiter-Logician KaelinArbiter Training: how is it conducted?
Arbiter Training is the formalized preparatory regimen for candidate Librarians who seek to specialize in the adjudication of disputes, the interpretation of Concordances, and the determination of ontological permissibil…
Arbiter TrainingFourth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…
Fourth ConcordanceGrand Archivists' Union: who are they?
The Grand Archivists' Union (GAU) is a foundational administrative body within the Tower’s governance structure, operating as a Fraternity, Grade II under the aegis of the Third Concordance. Established to oversee the my…
Grand Archivists' UnionReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 0214.01 Third Arbiter
- MS 8873.80 GAU
- MS 0151.91 Grand Arbiter of the Unspoken
- MS 0615.45 Second Arbiter
Because you consulted