The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Fl. 92

MS 6461.39 · Places and structures

Fl. 92

Fl. 92 is the designation given to an intermittent floor of the Tower, entered only by parties of no fewer than three, and catalogued—when it is catalogued at all—as a room of moderate size containing one table, one chair, and no further furniture. It is the smallest floor for which the Registrar's Niche maintains a standing entry, and the only one whose number is recorded in lowercase series (92) rather than the italic used elsewhere, a distinction the Niche has declined to explain on nine separate occasions.

The floor is reached by a stair on the eastern face between floors 41 and 44, though the interval has never been measured directly and is given variously in the survey returns as "short," "considerable," and "not to be attempted after the lamps are trimmed." Third Concordance, Annex 9, fixes the ascent at "no more than is needful," a phrase that has generated four centuries of commentary and no agreement.

First recorded entry

The earliest reliable account is the survey of Clerk Ondrast Vey, who entered Fl. 92 in the winter of the year the archive counts as 1138 and left a single line in the day-book: "Room as before. Chair warm." Vey's phrasing—"as before," on what is universally treated as a first visit—has never been satisfactorily resolved. The Curatorial Guild holds that the clerk was transcribing from an earlier return now lost; the Custodians of Closure hold that nothing was lost and the day-book is complete; and both cite Fl. 92, which neither can produce a second witness for, in support of their positions. The dispute is filed under Hall of Unfinished Inquiries and is expected to remain there.

Vey's return was countersigned by two witnesses, as the entry rule requires. Their names are legible. Their seals are not.

The chair

Every competent account of Fl. 92 mentions the warmth of the chair, and no account offers a mechanism. The Alchemists of the Seventh Silence proposed in their third recension that the chair retains the heat of its last occupant indefinitely, which would establish occupancy without identifying an occupant; the proposal was accepted into the working notes and has been used ever since to explain any anomaly in the room without requiring further inquiry. Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, is more cautious, recording only that "the chair is to be left as found," without specifying what "as found" denotes. A marginal hand—unattributed, but matching the script of the Archive of Unfinished Sentences—has written beside this clause: "It was found occupied."

The table is bare. Parties are instructed not to set anything on it. In 1246 a party of five left a candle stub on the table and reported, on descending, that the stair had brought them out on floor 41 twice in succession before releasing them on the third attempt. The incident is recorded without comment in the Annex Ω.1 returns.

Dispute over status

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether Fl. 92 is a floor at all. The Schism of the Unfinished Index turned in part on this question: the Index party maintained that a floor entered intermittently and catalogued inconsistently is not a holding but a gap in the holdings, and that numbering it grants it a permanence it does not possess. The counter-position, defended at length in the Curatorium of Unfinished Likenesses memorial of 1301, is that Fl. 92 possesses every property of a floor except continuity, and that continuity has never been required of floors, only assumed of them.

"A room that is not there when you look for it is still a room. A room that is there when you are not looking is a matter for the Custodians."

— Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, marginal gloss

No party has proposed that Fl. 92 be struck from the register. The motion was raised once, in 1302, and withdrawn before the vote on the grounds that withdrawal was cheaper than amendment.

Access and record

Inquiry regarding Fl. 92 must be submitted on Inquiry Form L-17, which bears the floor's designation in its fourth field and requires the petitioner to state whether they have previously entered the room. Petitioners who answer in the affirmative are routed to the Registrar's Niche; petitioners who answer in the negative are routed to the same place. The form's instructions note that a party of fewer than three will not find the stair, and that a party of more than three will find it, but not the same stair.


Scholars of Fl. 92 are advised that the room has no window and that the lamp, when lit, is to be extinguished on leaving. The stair is not to be counted on the way up. The floor's entry in the Chamber of Unfinished Symphonies adjacent register lists no sound, which is itself recorded as a sound by two of the three witnesses.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Curatorium of Unfinished Likenesses: who are they?

The Curatorium of Unfinished Likenesses is the administrative body responsible for the operations and custodianship of Floor 331: The Gallery of Unfinished Portraits and related subsidiary collections pertaining to incom…

Curatorium of Unfinished Likenesses
Chamber of Unfinished Symphonies: who are they?

“…a dedicated annex for the holding and arbitration of musical works whose state of completion is formally contested, inherently indeterminate, or exists solely within the penumbra between intention and resolution.”

Chamber of Unfinished Symphonies
Kaelen of the Unfinished Stair: who were they?

Kaelen of the Unfinished Stair (fl. Regency Era, Spiral 17,421–17,489†) was a Librarian-Steward whose commission of a second, ornate chair precipitated a prolonged administrative crisis and led directly to the current ac…

Kaelen of the Unfinished Stair
Curatorial Guild: who are they?

The Curatorial Guild is the principal administrative and doctrinal authority governing the systematic acquisition, classification, and maintenance of holdings within the Tower. Operating under the broad mandate of the Pr…

Curatorial Guild

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.