The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

FirstĠInquest

MS 3002.63 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and status

FirstĠInquest is a designation used in three Tower documents to denote what the catalogue otherwise records as the First Inquest, the First Inquest (Atlas of Whispers), and, in one disputed recension, the Second Inquest. The character between the two words is a gdot — a raised point set at mid-height rather than on the baseline — and its presence or absence has been the subject of repeated filing dispute since the 14,300s.

The designation appears on the spine labels of the Chamber of Recumbent Echoes proceedings, on the seal of the 12th of Deepwinter sitting, and in the marginal index of Inquest Ledger 97-Theta. It does not appear in the body text of any Concordance. Under Concordance III, Clauses 47 through 59, the First Inquest was convened under principles that make no reference to orthographic variation.

Origin of the character

The gdot is first recorded in the hand of Sub-Cantor Ennavet of the Scriptorium of Lower Registers, who was tasked in Tower Year 14,319 with producing clean copies of the Transcript of First Inquest Proceedings, Vol. I for distribution to the Inquisitors. Ennavet's exemplar — a carbon taken from a damp original — shows the point displaced upward, a defect Ennavet reported in writing to the Office of Fair Copying as "a raising of the full stop, the ink having climbed."

The Office did not rule on the report. Ennavet proceeded to set the designation in all seventy-one copies, and the raised point entered circulation without authorization. A surviving copy held in the archive of the Kael Inquest retains the defect; the remainder were corrected by hand in the 14,320s, though the corrections themselves are inconsistent, and several bear both forms on the same page.

Disputed scope

There is no agreement on whether the designation denotes a distinct event or merely a defective rendering of an existing one. Three positions are on record:

  • The Office of Fair Copying holds that FirstĠInquest and First Inquest are the same proceeding, and that the character is a copying error of no procedural weight.
  • The registrars of Inquest Ledger 502-Alpha treat FirstĠInquest as a separate convening, distinct in date from the First Inquest held in the Chamber of Recumbent Echoes, on the grounds that the ledger records two opening declarations for the same winter.
  • A minority position, advanced by Lectern Warden Sorrel and never adopted, holds that the gdot marks a proceeding convened and dissolved within a single afternoon, leaving no transcript and therefore no Inquest in the ordinary sense.

The Concordances do not settle the matter. The Second Concordance refers to "the First Inquest" throughout; the Third Concordance annexes a corrected index in which the character has been removed from every entry, only for the correction itself to be amended in a later recension restoring it. Readers consulting both will find each cited in support of the other's opposite.

Procedural consequences

The practical effect has been confined to citation. Because the designation differs by a single character, it does not resolve against the standard index, and petitions citing FirstĠInquest are routed by default to the office holding the nearest alphabetical match. Between Tower Years 14,326 and 14,341 this produced a backlog of eleven petitions concerning the status of holdings in the Structural Inquest register, all of which concerned the same shelf and none of which were read.

The backlog was cleared in the winter of 14,341 by Clerk-Marginal Harrow, who noted in the margin of Inquest Ledger 97-Theta that "the point is raised and the matter is not." Her note is now itself cited as authority, though only by parties who have not read the full entry.

Current practice

The Office of Fair Copying now permits both forms in working documents but requires the unraised form in anything presented to an Inquisitor. The seal of the Chamber of Recumbent Echoes continues to carry the gdot, on the ground that the seal is older than the ruling and that re-cutting it would raise a question about which sitting it commemorates. Visitors to the Chamber are asked not to photograph the seal directly; the ink is unstable and the point has climbed further in each of the last four documented inspections.

Whether the designation will survive the next recension of the marginal index is considered open. It has already survived three.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Kael Inquest: what happened?

The Kael Inquest was a formal investigation into the observer-dependent variance of The Lament of Kael, convened in Tower Year 14,388 under First Inquest protocols and closed eleven months later without a finding on the …

Kael Inquest
Concordance III: what does it set out?

Concordance III is a foundational instrument of the Tower's governance and the principal source of authority for all matters designated Tier III. It governs Tier-III processions and protocols, physical processions connec…

Concordance III
Inquest Ledger 502-Alpha: what does it set out?

Inquest Ledger 502-Alpha is a sub-classified administrative record, currently designated as Annex 7 to the Primary Aperture Registry, that documents the preparatory proceedings and procedural challenges leading to a form…

Inquest Ledger 502-Alpha
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.