The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Elara Contradiction

MS 5720.65 · Practices and doctrines

The Elara Contradiction is the collective designation given to a family of related archival disputes, filings, and ontological events clustering around the name Elara and spanning, in their recorded form, the period from the early fifth century YSP to the present administration. It is not a single contradiction but a station of them: the Contradiction Protocol groups the principal instances under one heading because, in the words of its own preamble, "the holdings resist separation without prejudice to any of the parties named Elara therein" (Contradiction Protocol, Preamble ii). The Contradiction is catalogued as Incisive-class, the classification reserved for contradictions that challenge a core operational tenet of the Tower rather than merely misdescribing a floor.

Citations to "the Elara Contradiction" in the singular ordinarily refer to the metadata dispute over the holdings of The Sigh of Elara, which remains unresolved and is expected to remain so.

The primary instance

Two entries for The Sigh of Elara were accessioned on the same day in YSP 428, from the same expedition, and disagreed as to whether the subject was to be classified as an acoustic residue or a devotional observance. Neither entry was withdrawn. The Librarians' practice at the time held that a signed entry could not be removed except by the signature of the clerk who had made it, and the clerk in question had by then been reassigned to a lower stack and could not be located for the purpose. Both entries were therefore allowed to stand, and the floor was given two catalogue drawers instead of one, which it retains.

The dispute was formally flagged in Contradiction Flagging records in YSP 841 by Scribe-Imperator Kael, who noted in the margin that the double accession had by then been cited in eleven separate floor inventories and that its removal would require the correction of all eleven. Kael declined to authorize the correction and recommended the filing be kept open. It has been kept open.

Involvement of the Elaras

The primary instance is complicated, and by some accounts constituted, by the number of persons and protocols bearing the name Elara whose rulings bear on it. Luminary Elara formalized the Contradiction in YSP 112, drawing on the rulings of Elara Pensworth; whether this formalization preceded the dispute it describes is a question the Concordances decline to settle. Archivist-Scribe Elara signed one of the two disputed entries and later, under a different designation, countersigned its withdrawal in a hand that the Office of Hands and Seals has declined to authenticate. Elara, Ninth of that Designation is recorded in the Ninth Register of Designations as having no connection to the matter at all, a finding she successfully petitioned to have entered into the record.

Librarian-Scribe Elara Vex appears throughout the file with unusual countersignatures — seals applied in the wrong margin, dates entered twice in different recensions — which the audit of YSP 848 treated as a distinct Contradiction under the same heading.

Separately, the Elara Protocol and the Precedential Loop of Elara Vance are held by some readers to be simultaneously valid, producing what has been called a self-negating ontological paradox. The Standing Committee on Precedential Weight has ruled twice that this paradox is "administrative in character and does not require resolution" (Standing Committee, Ruling 44-C). One further strand of the file concerns a single entity recorded as holding the roles of Tender and Cartographer-Scribe at once, which the Concordance of Roles, Third Recension prohibits without exception.

Resolution and the seven-year Audit

Following the Concordance Contradiction Ruling of YSP 460, the Contradiction was subjected to a seven-year Audit, concluded in YSP 467. The Audit did not resolve the Contradiction. It resolved the conditions of the Contradiction, which is to say it established a schedule under which the two entries could be consulted in sequence without either being preferred. The schedule is reprinted at Annex 7 of the Audit Report and is four pages long. The floor's two catalogue drawers were relabelled to reflect the sequence.

"The Audit finds that the entries cannot be reconciled, that they need not be, and that the question of preference is outside its remit. The Committee notes that both drawers are to be kept locked outside the hours of consultation."

— Seven-Year Audit of the Elara Contradiction, Annex 7

Scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute among later commentators concerns the Contradiction's size. The Bureau of Contradiction Weights assigns it 3.2 Standard Contradiction Units, on the basis of the Elaran Migration assertions alone; the Bureau's figure is the one most commonly cited and is the figure printed in the Protocol. Contradiction Loading, however, has argued in three successive memoranda that the figure omits the Vex countersignatures and understates the load by as much as a third, and that the floor should be rated at 4.1 SCU and accordingly reinforced.

The Concordance of Weights and Measures, Fifth Recension fixes the SCU at the mass of one sealed ledger and forbids its subdivision beyond two decimal places. The Third Recension, still in force on certain floors, subdivides freely and was the authority under which the 3.2 figure was first entered. The two recensions have not been reconciled, and the Bureau has asked that the question not be put to it again.

A minority position, associated with the Reading Room of Contradictory Holdings, holds that the Contradiction is best understood not as a dispute about Elara at all but as a dispute about drawers, and that its persistence owes more to the relabelling than to the entries. The Reading Room's pamphlet on the subject has been withdrawn from circulation twice and returned to the shelves both times.

Related holdings

The Contradiction is cross-referenced in the Protocol to Direct Contradiction, Contradiction Resolution, Contradiction Warrens, and Elara's Protocol for Dissonant Archives, the last of which is filed under a different Elara and has been the cause of some confusion at the consultation desk.

The Tower's holdings on the Elara Contradiction occupy four shelves on the relevant floor and are consulted by appointment only.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Contradiction Resolution: how is it conducted?

Contradiction Resolution is the formal administrative process by which the Tower determines the standing, shelving, and catalogical status of a recorded contradiction, from its first Contradiction Flagging through to its…

Contradiction Resolution
Luminary Elara: how is it conducted?

Luminary Elara refers to a singular, unresolved instance of an Attainment-level discrepancy within the Catalog of Luminaries, recorded in Tower Year 8,347. While the title "Luminary Elara" is referenced in numerous Third…

Luminary Elara
Direct Contradiction: how is it conducted?

The term Direct Contradiction is the formal designation, under Article 2 of the Contradiction Protocol, for a Contradiction in which two documented assertions oppose one another without the intervention of any intermedia…

Direct Contradiction
Elara Vex: who were they?

Elara Vex (Registry Code: EV-XII-K) was a Senior Librarian and theorist chiefly noted for articulating the principles of Circulationism in her seminal, though unpublished, treatise On the Fluidity of Knowledge. Her caree…

Elara Vex

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.