The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Edicts of Precedence

MS 6980.28 · Practices and doctrines

The Edicts of Precedence are the class of doctrinal instruments by which the Tower records which of two conflicting rules shall be obeyed first. They do not create rules and they do not repeal them; they arrange rules, and their authority rests entirely on the claim — asserted in Series Ω (Omega) Edicts of Precedence and never since examined — that precedence itself may be conferred instrumentally, as one confers a seal or a floor number, rather than earned by age, specificity, or merit. The class is entered in the register maintained under Edicts of Precedence, and its operations are given physical form in the Vault of Precedence on floor 8-R, where the instruments are stored spine-outward in order of the precedence they confer, so that the shelf itself constitutes a reading of the law.

Classification and scope

The Edicts of Precedence are among the highest order of Doctrinal Edicts, establishing irreversible first principles; the Precedence Edicts proper are the instruments issued under them, and the two names are frequently confused in correspondence, a confusion the Hall of Foundational Edicts has declined to correct on the grounds that correction would itself require a precedence ruling. Edict of Precedence, the founding instrument, fixed the category and established that precedence is conferred and not discovered. Instruments drafted in the same cycle are ranked by the separate schedule at Precedence Edict 22/1.

The class sits above Procedural Edicts and Operational Edicts and below any applicable Concordance. It is expressly subordinate to Spire Edicts, which hold ultimate precedence across the whole of the Edicts Amp Directives system and derive their force from the Volumetric-Temporal Edicts. A reader who finds this arrangement circular is referred to the standing note in the Vault vestibule, which states simply that the reader is not the first and that the matter is settled.

The reading of 14 Frost, 3rd Session

In the winter of the 3rd Session, on floor 8-R, a dispute arose over whether the Vault's own shelving order could be cited as precedent. Clerk Amarin Vell, then of the second scriptorium, argued that because the shelf arranged instruments by the precedence they conferred, the shelf was a ruling, and a ruling could be cited. The Librarian on duty ruled that the shelf was a shelf. Vell appealed, and the appeal was heard under a Precedence Edict which — because the parties could not agree which edition was current — was read aloud from three recensions in succession, each of which assigned precedence differently. The appeal was accordingly resolved twice in favour of each party.

"Where an instrument is cited against itself, the citation is deemed to have been made twice, and the second citation is struck."

— Series Ω (Omega) Edicts of Precedence, Annex 3, clause 11

Vell was reassigned to the north stairwell in the following session and filed no further appeals. The three recensions remain in the Vault, shelved in the order they were read, which is not the order of the precedence they confer.

Interaction with the Concordances

Precedence Edicts settle disputes between Series; the Third Concordance settles disputes about the Edicts. Where the two meet, the Concordance prevails, and this has produced a documented class of instruments that are valid, irreversibly established, and of no effect. The Edicts of Mediate Resolution were drafted to address this by deferring each conflict to the next, a solution that has run for four sessions without reaching a determination and is generally regarded as working. The Causality Edicts are excluded from the class entirely, on the ground that an edict which must precede itself in order to confer precedence on itself cannot be shelved.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute concerns whether precedence is conferred at drafting or at first citation. The instrumental view, defended in Edicts of Precedence and taught in the second scriptorium, holds that an edict confers precedence the moment it is sealed and entered, whether or not anyone has read it since. The citationist view, held chiefly in the first scriptorium, observes that an instrument unread for four sessions has settled nothing, and that the Vault's own indices record such instruments as dormant. Neither view has been able to explain the Omega-12 Precedence Edict, which was entered, sealed, shelved, and — according to the accession ledger — cited in a matter that had not yet arisen. The ledger entry is initialled and dated and has not been amended. The Edict of Terrestrial Resonance is sometimes offered as a parallel case, though the comparison is contested.

Access and handling

The Vault of Precedence is open to accredited readers on the second and fifth days of the session. Instruments may not be reshelved by readers, and readers are asked not to read aloud in the Vault, as the acoustics of 8-R return a reading to the reader in the order it was spoken rather than the order it was written, which has on two occasions been mistaken for an amendment. Copying is permitted in the antechamber only. The antechamber has no chairs.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Hall of Foundational Edicts: where is it?

The Hall of Foundational Edicts is the custodial chamber in which the Tower's originating instruments are stored, read aloud, and — on occasion — amended without notice. It occupies a single unnumbered floor between the …

Hall of Foundational Edicts
Doctrinal Edicts: how is it conducted?

Doctrinal Edicts constitute the primary codified instruments through which the foundational administrative philosophy of the Librarians is articulated, amended, and enforced. Distinct from the broader category of Tower E…

Doctrinal Edicts
Edict of Precedence: what does it set out?

The Edict of Precedence is the generic designation given to any document promulgated under the Issuance of a Precedence Edict and entered into the register of Edicts of Precedence. An Edict of Precedence does not itself …

Edict of Precedence
Edicts of Precedence (Series Ω): what does it set out?

Edicts of Precedence (Series Ω) are the instruments by which the Edict of Precedence is applied to contested matters, and together they form the operative corpus of Series Ω practice. Where an Edict of Precedence defines…

Edicts of Precedence (Series Ω)

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.