The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Dry Cataloguing

MS 2182.11 · Practices and doctrines

Dry Cataloguing is the branch of archival practice concerned with the registration, placement, and maintenance of holdings that neither invite nor retain moisture, and with the procedures by which such holdings are distinguished from those merely awaiting desiccation. It is administered jointly by the Office of Substantive Assessment and the Dry Cataloguing Bench on Floor 812, though the division of labour between the two has been disputed since the Bound Margin settlement of 3,197. Roughly one floor in nine is given over to dry holdings. Nobody has counted them recently.

Dry Cataloguing is not to be confused with the Doctrine of Dry Souls, although the two share a vocabulary and, on at least four recorded occasions, a filing cabinet. Dry Souls concerns insufficiency of metaphysical substance; Dry Cataloguing concerns absence of water. A holding may be thoroughly wet and have no soul at all; this is noted but not acted upon.

Origins and the First Bench

The practice formalised in the winter of 2,988, when an unseasonal damp in the eastern stacks reduced a consignment of salt tablets to a single fused block weighing eleven and a half stone. The then-Keeper of Shelves, Keeper Ilse Morrow, is credited with the observation that the tablets had been "catalogued wet and shelved hopeful," a formulation that survives in the Bench's standing preamble. The Second Concordance, Annex 6, established that any holding registering below a fixed threshold of retained moisture should be entered in a separate register — the Dry Ledger — and shelved no fewer than nine courses from any open water.

The nine-course rule has been amended fourteen times. It remains nine courses. A visiting reader is asked not to bring beverages above Floor 806.

Procedure and the Damp Interval

Assessment proceeds by weighing the holding, waiting, and weighing it again. The interval between weighings is the Damp Interval, during which the holding is neither dry nor attentive and may be legibly consulted. Intervals are recorded in minutes and, where the weather on the stair is unsettled, in "long minutes," a unit defined in the Concordance of the Bound Margin, Schedule 3, as "a minute observed from the north side."

Where a holding's status cannot be settled by weight alone, the Bench permits the use of a Hygroscopic Pendulum, though the instrument is properly the property of the Sect of the Thirsty Page and must be borrowed in writing. Disputes over pendulums account for a substantial fraction of the Bench's correspondence. In 3,204 the Wardens of the Dry Spiral invoked Clause 117c.4 of Ordinance 117c to restrain a Bench clerk from swinging a borrowed pendulum over an open recension cask; the Wardens prevailed, and the pendulum was returned with a note.

The Halloway Grievance

The most cited internal quarrel concerns Clerk Enna Halloway, who between 3,188 and 3,201 maintained that her register of desiccated victuals had been misfiled under the Department of Ephemeral Cataloguing and thereby removed from her authority. The Bench contended that the register had never been hers, citing Amendment 14-B of the Seventh Concordance, which reserves to the Bench "all provender however dry." Halloway replied, in a memorandum of 3,194 that is preserved chiefly because it was copied to eleven offices, that provender is not a category but a habit.

"The Bench may have the salt. It may not have the register of the salt, which I made myself and which is legible."

— E. Halloway, memorandum to the Dry Cataloguing Bench, 3,194

The matter was resolved by Cataloguing Dispute Resolution in 3,201 in favour of the Bench, on the grounds that the register had by then absorbed enough ambient moisture to be reclassified. Halloway was reassigned to the Sector Theta Re-cataloguing Project and is not recorded as having complained again.

Scholarly Disagreement

Two positions persist. The first, associated with the Bench and defended at length in the Fourth Concordance, holds that dryness is a measurable property and that the Dry Ledger is therefore a record of fact. The second, advanced by the Sect of the Thirsty Page and given its fullest statement in the Eleventh Concordance, Annex 2, holds that dryness is a relation between a holding and its surroundings, and that a ledger of it is a ledger of weather. The Eleventh was amended to say so before the Fourth was sealed, and the two have never been reconciled.

The Principle of Dry Precedence is sometimes invoked to settle the question. It does not, chiefly because both postulates are equally dry. A proposal to refer the matter to the Meta-cataloguing subcommittee has been tabled at every session since 3,206 and has not yet been read.

Recorded Difficulties

Three classes of error recur. First, the misclassification of a merely cold holding as dry, which is common in the northern stacks and was the subject of the suppressed error register of 3,199. Second, the transit of a dry holding through a damp floor, which requires a Dry Recension of its accompanying papers if the papers take water; the recension of volumes 88–94 of the Scriptorium Supply Ledgers remains the standard example. Third, the enclosure of dry stores and single ingredients in recension casks without the Bench's countersignature, a practice the Bench discourages and the kitchens ignore.

The Model IV Cataloguing Automaton is not permitted in the dry stacks, following an incident in 3,202 involving condensation and a great deal of paperwork. The automaton has been asked not to return. It has not been asked twice.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Doctrine of Dry Souls: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Dry Souls is a classificatory principle and procedural framework governing the cataloguing of entities whose metaphysical "substance" is considered insufficient to warrant standard accession. It serves as…

Doctrine of Dry Souls
Cataloguing Dispute Resolution: how is it conducted?

Cataloguing Dispute Resolution is the specialized sub-field of Dispute Resolution concerned with the adjudication of procedural, classificatory, and archival conflicts arising from the cataloguing process itself. Unlike …

Cataloguing Dispute Resolution
Scriptorium Supply Ledgers: what does it set out?

The Scriptorium Supply Ledgers are a bound series of 214 volumes recording the receipt, assay, and release of materials issued to the Central Scriptorium and its dependent scriptoria between the winters of 3112 and 3489.…

Scriptorium Supply Ledgers
Meta-cataloguing: how is it conducted?

Meta-cataloguing is the Tower practice of recording the act of recording, as distinct from cataloguing, which records holdings. The distinction is maintained by the Guild of Meta-Cataloguers and defended in every generat…

Meta-cataloguing

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.