The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Contemporary Humoral Cartography

MS 6630.55 · Practices and doctrines

Contemporary Humoral Cartography is the collective designation for those practices, instruments, and schools that apply the four-humour framework of Humoral Cartography to surveys conducted after the dissolution of the School of Humoral Cartography in Year 151. The term is administrative rather than doctrinal: nothing in the body of contemporary practice differs in principle from the methods of the original School, and the distinction is maintained chiefly so that surveys filed after Year 151 can be assigned a different fee schedule under Ninth Concordance, Annex 2. Contemporary practitioners object to this.

Origins and the Great Recalibration

The Humoral Spire was decommissioned and dismantled following the Great Recalibration, and the School that had operated from it was formally dissolved the same year. Its instruments were dispersed, its records placed under seal, and its surveyors reassigned to the Department of Cartography, which had by then approved Humoral Cartography as the standard method for preliminary surveys for six decades and saw no reason to abandon a procedure merely because its authors had gone.

The first use of the phrase "contemporary" in this connection appears in a marginal note by the clerk Ovett Marsh in the survey register for Floor 212, dated to the winter of Year 153. Marsh had been asked to reconcile two overlapping survey claims and wrote, in the flat register hand of the period, that the older claim was "of the Spire" and the newer "of the contemporary practice, though the compass has not changed." The note was copied into four subsequent registers and, by Year 160, had hardened into a category. Marsh received no credit and appears to have sought none.

"The compass has not changed. The fee has."

— Ovett Marsh, survey register, Floor 212

Method

Contemporary Humoral Cartography retains the four humoral climates — Sanguine, Choleric, Phlegmatic, and Melancholic — and the triplicate reading by which a climate is established. A surveyor records the initial impression of a chamber, then withdraws to a fixed distance of not less than eleven paces, then re-enters and records the impression again. Where the three readings agree, the climate is entered plainly. Where they do not, the chamber is marked disputed and referred upward to the next numbered floor, which is ordinarily two floors above, and occasionally one floor below.

The principal departure from the School's practice is the treatment of inheritance. The School held that a chamber's climate derived from its construction and its occupants in roughly equal measure. Contemporary practice holds that construction predominates, and that occupant influence dissipates within a stated period — generally three days for transient occupants, and forty years for permanent fixtures such as shelving. This has made contemporary surveys considerably cheaper to conduct, since chambers need not be surveyed twice around a change of use.

The question of continuity

Whether Contemporary Humoral Cartography is a continuation of the original practice or a separate discipline is a live dispute, and one that the Concordances have made worse rather than better.

Fourth Concordance, Annex 7, asserts that "the practice survives its instruments," and treats contemporary surveyors as the direct successors of the School, entitled to cite its sealed records. Eleventh Concordance, Annex 1, asserts the reverse: that dissolution terminates method as well as institution, and that any survey conducted after Year 151 is a new work requiring new certification. Neither annex has been repealed. The Bureau of Contradictory Cartography has declined to reconcile them, noting in a widely circulated memorandum of Year 204 that it is "not the office of this Bureau to make the archive consistent, only to record that it is not."

The practical consequence is that a contemporary survey may be filed as either a continuation or an original work, and surveyors choose according to whether they wish to inherit the School's disputed liabilities. Most do not.

Relationship to other schools

Contemporary Humoral Cartography is one of several bodies of practice claiming descent from the dissolved School. The School of Latent Structure synthesizes its principles for the mapping of concealed architecture. The School of Predictive Curation adapts its methods to the measurement of the "pressure" of unmanifest potential, a quantity the original School never measured and, on the evidence of its surviving registers, never conceived of. The Progressive Cartography School regards both as decadent and says so at length in its annual address.

Relations with the Office of Ephemeral Cartography are cordial but distant, the two practices differing chiefly on whether a chamber's climate can be said to exist at all where the chamber is scheduled for removal. Contemporary surveyors hold that it can, and that the climate of a chamber due for demolition is in fact the most reliable reading available, since nothing further is expected of it.

Certification and current standing

Certification is granted by the Department of Cartography on the recommendation of two existing certificate-holders, one of whom must have surveyed the applicant's floor of residence. The the Spire itself is no longer available for calibration, and contemporary surveyors calibrate instead against a fixed series of readings taken from Floor 88, which has not changed climate since Year 149 and is accordingly closed to the public. A letter of Year 231 from the Keeper of Floor 88 records that the closure is "for the preservation of the reading, not the visitors," and that applications to view it should be submitted in triplicate, as is customary, and not in person.

Current standing is uncertain. The discipline maintains roughly three hundred certified surveyors, no central registry, and a scholarly literature consisting almost entirely of disputes over the Fourth and Eleventh Concordances. Its defenders note that it is the only surviving practice descended from the School that still files its surveys on time.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Ephemeral Cartography: who are they?

Office of Ephemeral Cartography (OEC) is the primary administrative and regulatory body overseeing the practice of Ephemeral Cartography within the Tower. Formally established under Clause 412 of the Register of Ephemera…

Office of Ephemeral Cartography
Bureau of Contradictory Cartography: who are they?

The Bureau of Contradictory Cartography is the subsidiary agency of the Department of Cartography responsible for the identification, verification, and formal deposition of maps that negate their own validity or the exis…

Bureau of Contradictory Cartography
Great Recalibration: what happened?

The Great Recalibration was a formal, system-wide review and adjustment of standard measuring paradigms within the Tower, conventionally dated to the primary span of Year 149-150. Instigated by a series of Librarian orde…

Great Recalibration
Department of Cartography: who are they?

Department of Cartography is the primary administrative body within The Librarians responsible for the creation, maintenance, and canonical interpretation of all spatial records pertaining to the Tower's interior, includ…

Department of Cartography

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.