The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance of Deferred Positions

MS 9957.70 · Documents and ordinances

The Concordance of Deferred Positions is the forty-first of the numbered Concordances of the Tower's standing body of governance, promulgated in the winter of the year recorded in the Register of Deferred Actions as Cycle 11,407, and revised nine times, most recently under seal of the Chamber of Deferred Judgement. It establishes the class of deferred positions — coordinates held to be true but not yet asserted — and sets out the conditions under which such positions may be lodged, shelved, cited, or allowed to lapse. Its founding clause has been quoted in more disputes than any passage outside the Concordance of Positions:

"That which is known but not declared does not stand; that which is declared but not known shall stand until contradicted; and that which is neither shall wait, in order, on the appropriate floor."

— Concordance of Deferred Positions, Preamble, clause i

The Concordance's jurisdiction is difficult to state without circularity, a difficulty its own drafters anticipated and did not resolve.

Origin and the Aperture Dispute

The Concordance arose from a procedural failure at the aperture between Floors 3,116 and 3,117, where the Register of Asserted Positions had for two cycles received coordinates for which no asserting Librarian could be produced. The keeper of that register, Under-Clerk Mirenne Vhal, refused to strike them on the grounds that unstruck coordinates had never caused the Tower to fall. The Concordance of Deferred Questions was convened to hear the matter and, in a decision still cited, declined to decide it, recommending instead that the unnamed positions "be given a form of holding in which they may rest without consequence" (Concordance of Deferred Questions, Session 12, minute 4). The Concordance of Deferred Positions is that form of holding.

Vhal is the document's principal author and its most persistent critic. A marginal annotation in her hand, preserved in the working recension, reads: "This clause will not survive its own annexes" (Working Recension C, folio 212, verso). She was correct twice.

The Deferred Register and the Fourth Floor Below

Lodging a deferred position requires only that the coordinate be entered in the Ledger of Positions with the hour of entry, the floor of entry, and the name of the Librarian present — a name that, under Annex 4, may be that of a Librarian who has since been reassigned, provided the reassignment is itself deferred. The Register of Asserted Positions receives the entries twice yearly and revises them at each cycle's close, as the Ledger of Positions requires of all its derivatives.

Annex 4 is the source of the Concordance's most litigated defect. By permitting a reassigned Librarian to serve as the name on an entry, it permits in practice an entry to be countersigned by no one presently on the floor on which it rests. The Spatial Verifiers challenged this arrangement in the inquiry recorded as Verification Cycle 44-B, demonstrating that Floor 4,091 held eleven deferred positions attributed to Librarians whose reassignment was itself deferred to Floor 4,091. The positions rested on the authority of each other. The Chamber of Deferred Judgement upheld the entries, noting that they had not moved.

Relation to Provisional Positions

The Concordance is frequently confused with the earlier Concordance of Provisional Positions, whose Annex 9, clause iii, holds that "a number softly given is nonetheless given, and shall be given a place." The distinction is doctrinal and, some argue, ornamental. A provisional position is a claim not yet fit for assertion; a deferred position is an assertion not yet fit for its claim. The first waits for verification. The second waits for a speaker.

The Ordinance of Provisional Positions treats the two classes as one for purposes of its prohibition on citation below Floor 819, a conflation the Concordance of Provisional Positions has never protested and the Concordance of Deferred Positions has never forgiven. Librarian-Auditor Osric Pell argued in a note of Cycle 11,390 that the conflation had cost the Tower "at least four floors of the lower annexes, which now hold nothing and cannot say so" (Pell, Marginalia on the Lower Annexes).

Amendment and the Quen Lapse

Seven of the Concordance's nine revisions concern the status of positions held at a Librarian's death. The Archive of Superseded Positions, established by the Sixty-Seventh Concordance, Clause 12, received the bequest of Under-Secretary Halvard Quen in Cycle 11,362, comprising some nineteen hundred deferred positions, none of which had been declared in his lifetime. Under the Concordance as then amended, they were superseded on receipt and could not be reasserted. The Archive's recording of the bequest remains its largest single accession and the only one for which the accession number was assigned before the holding was described.

The current text permits such positions to be re-lodged once, at the floor of the deceased's last assignment, subject to the verification required by Concordance 44, Annex 2. Of the approximately eight thousand positions re-lodged under this provision in the last three cycles, none has been verified. None has been struck.

Disputes

The [Chamber of Deferred Judgements]] holds that the Concordance applies only to positions lodged by Librarians of the third grade and above; the [Chamber of Deferred Judgement]] holds that it applies to all Librarians and to no one else. Both chambers cite the same preamble. Neither has amended its reading, and the Chamber of Deferred Judgement Place has ruled on the question twice, in opposite directions, without noting the earlier ruling.

A minor quarrel, unresolved for three hundred cycles, concerns whether the page on which a deferred position is entered counts toward the ledger in the sense prohibited by the Concordance of Positions during the Great Ligature Schism. The Fifth Concordance counts the page; the Concordance of Deferred Positions is silent. In practice the page is counted on alternate cycles.

Positions may not be carried through the stairwell between Floors 2,204 and 2,206 during the hours of rest. The restriction is not enforced.

Current Standing

The Concordance of Deferred Positions remains in force and remains, by the count of the Registry of Positions, the most cited and least applied instrument in the Tower's holdings. Its central doctrine — that a position may be held without being held — is taught to new Librarians in their first month and corrected in their second. Enquiries concerning its application to Floor 22,991 are directed, as all such enquiries are, to the Registry of Positions, which does not answer them.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Great Ligature Schism: what happened?

The Great Ligature Schism was a sixty-one-year orthographic crisis concerning the cataloguing status of ligatures, spanning Archive Era 11,901. to 11,907.π. It is the longest recorded dispute in the Tower over whether a …

Great Ligature Schism
Register of Deferred Actions: what does it set out?

Register of Deferred Actions is the Tower-wide ledger by which actions deemed premature, unverifiable, or lacking a recorded baseline are formally suspended pending further concordance. Administered in parallel to the lo…

Register of Deferred Actions
Fifth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…

Fifth Concordance
Chamber of Deferred Judgement Place: where is it?

The Chamber of Deferred Judgement Place is the term used throughout the Concordance series for the physical seat of the Chamber of Deferred Judgement, as distinct from the body that occupies it. The distinction is of lon…

Chamber of Deferred Judgement Place

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.