The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance Nine

MS 6690.26 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance Nine is the ninth of the Nine Foundational Ordinances and the shortest of the first ten by folio count, occupying eleven leaves in its received form. It is not to be confused with the Ninth Concordance, which is a separate instrument of later date, nor with the Ninth Spiral of the Spiral Nine, which is a place and not a document at all. Concordance Nine governs duplication — what may be listed twice, on what authority, and in what hand.

The distinction is the source of nearly every dispute concerning the instrument. The clerks of the Reclamation Desk, Spiral Nine maintain the working position that Concordance Nine was drafted to prevent the double-registration of stair-plates, and that all other applications are accidental. The Guild of Structural Logicians has never accepted this and cites the preamble, which speaks of "every article of the Tower's keeping, whether stone, word, or person."

Article 2 and the Lamp on Floor 611

The best-known provision of Concordance Nine is Article 2, which states that the central lamp on Floor 611 may only be serviced by a Lampwarden accompanied by a non-speaking witness. The clause has been read as a safety measure, as a devotional requirement, and — in a minority opinion filed by Archivist Halloway Venn in the winter of the 4,112 expedition — as a rule about testimony, the witness being present to see and not to say.

In practice the third reading has prevailed by default. Lampwardens serving Floor 611 are drawn from a rota maintained at the Reclamation Desk, and the witness is customarily a junior clerk of the Guild of Structural Logicians in their first quarter. Witnesses are instructed to stand at the foot of the ladder and to keep their hands folded. Three witnesses in the last century have been reprimanded for humming.

"The witness shall not speak before, during, or within the hour following the service, and shall not be asked afterwards what was seen, the asking being itself a form of speaking."

— Concordance Nine, Article 2, gloss appended by the Third Concordance, Annex 12

The Rule Against Double Listing

Article 5 carries the instrument's central prohibition: no Chapter numbered less than nine shall be listed twice. The wording has been the subject of continuous commentary since at least the fourth recension of the Concordance of Recensions. Its difficulty is grammatical. The clause does not say what a Chapter is, nor whether it is the Chapter that may not be listed twice or the listing that may not recur.

The Third Concordance and its nine recensions adopted the second reading, and it is this reading that appears in every index issued since. The Concordance of Recensions records the disagreement without resolving it, noting only that "the two readings have never been tested against a Chapter small enough to settle the matter."

They were tested, once, in the spring following the recovery of the stamped stair-plate from Floor 4,112 bearing the mark of the Foundry Concordance of Nine. A junior cataloguer listed Chapter 4 of the plate's accompanying schedule on two consecutive mornings. The duplication was detected by the Reclamation Desk, Spiral Nine before the second entry was sealed. The clerk's defense — that the Chapter had been listed once as an object and once as a description — was heard and rejected, and the schedule was withdrawn from circulation for eleven months. The episode is cited in Concordance 743, Annex 9 as an example of the rule working as intended.

Relationship to the Silent Amendments

Concordance Nine was among the instruments altered by the Nine Silent Amendments, though the alteration is not visible in the received text. The Amendments were embedded into Tower law through the Second Concordance and its Appendices, and the practice of the order has been to record their effect in the margins of the affected documents rather than in their bodies.

The margin of Concordance Nine, Article 5, carries a mark in the hand of the drafting clerk Ovin Marrow, whose working copy of the Seventh Concordance, Revision 12 is held at Scriptorium Nine. The mark is a single vertical stroke, unexplained. Marrow's marginalia elsewhere are voluble; this one is not, and no gloss of it has ever been accepted by the Concordance of Recensions.

Scholarly dispute

The Guild of Structural Logicians holds that Concordance Nine was amended wholesale by the Silent Amendments and that its received text is therefore a reconstruction, not an original. They point to the instrument's brevity, its irregular foliation, and the absence of the seal that appears on every other ordinance of the first ten.

The Librarians have not ruled on the question. The position of the Reclamation Desk, Spiral Nine is that the seal is present and has simply been misfiled, a claim it has maintained since the desk's establishment and has never substantiated. In the interim, the text is cited as received. Citing Concordance Nine remains the standard method of settling a dispute about duplication, and disputants are advised to bring a copy of their own, as the Desk's working copy is on loan.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Concordance 743, Annex 9: how is it conducted?

Concordance 743, Annex 9 is a nine-leaf administrative annex to Concordance 743, issued by the Office of Marginal Instruments in the eleventh year of the current recension and revised twice since. It governs the disposal…

Concordance 743, Annex 9
Guild of Structural Logicians: who are they?

The Guild of Structural Logicians (GSL) is one of the Nine Concordant Guilds of the Tower, accredited under the Fourth Concordance, Annex Δ. Its charter, established by the Sixth Concordance, is the "resolution of spatia…

Guild of Structural Logicians
Nine Silent Amendments: how is it conducted?

Nine Silent Amendments are a set of administrative reforms embedded into Tower law through the Second Concordance, concerning the conduct, recording, and non-announcement of silent procedures across the vertical library-…

Nine Silent Amendments
Seventh Concordance, Revision 12: what does it set out?

Seventh Concordance, Revision 12 is the final and currently operative revision of the foundational administrative charter for the Seventh Spiral Administrative Spire. Ratified on the 22nd day of the Third Spiral, 781, it…

Seventh Concordance, Revision 12

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.