The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Codicil of Perpendicular Doubt

MS 6174.92 · Documents and ordinances

The Codicil of Perpendicular Doubt is a supplementary instrument appended to the Perpendicular Recess Directive in the winter of the year recorded in the Register of Purification as Cycle 44, Entry 19, and subsequently reaffirmed, with modifications, at each of the eleven recensions of that Directive held in the Perpendicular Atrium. It governs the treatment of doubt arising not within a standing Perpendicular Recess but at its margins — the narrow band, usually between four and nine gradia thick, in which a Perpendicular Recess is real to some parties and not to others. The Codicil is short (three leaves, one of them blank by intention) and is described in the Directive's own preamble as "an interpretive annex, subordinate in all things to the body of the instrument it amends."

Origin

The Codicil arose from the so-called Winter of the Twice-Measured Door, when a working recess on the eastern side of Floor 712: The Repository of Measured Doubt was recorded as open by two separate clerks of the Order of the Perpendicular Door and closed by a third, all within the same hour. The two opening records agreed on the hour but disagreed on the width of the recess by eleven gradia, and the clearing record could not be matched to either. The matter was referred upward in the ordinary way, but the ordinary way had not previously contemplated a recess open and closed at once, and the reviewing officers found themselves unable to proceed without a statement of principle. That statement was drafted by an officer of the Perpendicular Atrium named Sereth Vole, whose marginal note survives in the working copy: "The difficulty is not the door. The difficulty is the doubt about the door, which arrived first and has not left."

Vole's draft was not, strictly, accepted. It was appended. The distinction matters to its later history: because the Codicil was never voted into the Directive's body, it has the force of an interpretive gloss rather than of an operative clause, and can be amended by any officer of sufficient seniority without reference to the Concordance of Openings and Clearings that otherwise governs recess procedure.

Provisions

The Codicil's operative content is contained in three numbered heads. The first directs that where a recess is recorded open and closed within the same hour, the later record prevails, "and the earlier shall be struck through, not erased, so that the doubt of the second clerk remains legible to the auditor." The second holds that doubt arising at the margin of a recess shall be attributed to the recess and not to the practitioner — a point that the Skeptical Archivists have contested for four recensions, on the ground that it makes the practitioner invisible to the record precisely at the moment their uncertainty is greatest. The third head is the shortest and most cited: "The margin is not a place. It is a duration."

Procedurally, the Codicil attaches itself to the Doubt Gradient by treating the gradient's rise outward from the Plinth of the First Doubt as the measure of the margin. Recesses whose boundary falls below four gradia are, in practice, exempt from the Codicil's heads, a threshold nowhere stated in the text and derived from a note in the Treatise on Perpendicular Time, Book II, folio 31, which is itself unclear on the point.

"Where the margin exceeds the recess, the recess is to be understood as the doubt and the doubt as the recess; the clearance shall be recorded regardless."

— The Perpendicular Recess Directive, Recension Nine, Annex delta, third head of the Codicil

Dispute

The principal scholarly dispute concerns the Codicil's relation to the Directive's exclusion clause. The Directive excludes from its protections those intervals "in which the doubt of the practitioner is the object," a phrase the Skeptical Archivists read as carving out precisely the margins the Codicil claims to govern — and therefore as rendering the Codicil void wherever it is most needed. The Order of the Perpendicular Door maintains the contrary: that the Codicil does not protect the practitioner's doubt but absorbs it into the recess, at which point it ceases to be the practitioner's and ceases to be the object of anything. The disagreement has never been resolved, and both readings are cited in the current opening returns.

A second, narrower dispute concerns the blank third leaf. The Codicil's copyists have consistently left it blank, and a note in the Register of Purification, Entry 44/19, records the reason as "precautionary." Three recensions have attempted to fill it; each attempt has been struck through rather than erased, in accordance with the Codicil's own first head, and the leaf is today more crowded with struck-through text than any other page in the instrument.

Application

In practice the Codicil is invoked most often at shift change, when a recess opened by one clerk is inherited by another and the margin has thickened overnight. Officers of the Order are instructed to read the Codicil aloud at the threshold before entering an inherited recess; the reading may be abbreviated to the third head where the recess is narrow, though the abbreviation is itself disputed. The Motif of Perpendicular Time illustrates the procedure in its seventh figure, in which a clerk is shown reading from a single leaf in a doorway of uncertain width.

Copies of the Codicil are held in the Perpendicular Atrium and in the working collection of Floor 712: The Repository of Measured Doubt. The Floor 712 copy is annotated throughout in Vole's hand and is the basis for all eleven recensions. It may not be borrowed. Clerks wishing to consult it outside the reading room must apply in writing to the Keeper of the Floor, who is presently also the Keeper of the Codicil, and who has not answered an application since Cycle 51.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Register of Purification: what does it set out?

The Register proceeds in seventy-two numbered steps, grouped into nine phases of eight. The phases are named, in order: Arrival, Doubt, Stripping, Weighing, Doubt Renewed, Reassembly, Silence, Sealing, and Discharge. The…

Register of Purification
Plinth of the First Doubt: what is it for?

The Plinth of the First Doubt (Catalog Designation 712.α.1) is a foundational basalt monolith located in the Hall of Inception on Floor 712: The Repository of Measured Doubt. It is formally defined as the physical instan…

Plinth of the First Doubt
Floor 712: The Repository of Measured Doubt: where is it?

Floor 712: The Repository of Measured Doubt is a floor of the Tower designated by Concordance 712-A and subsequently reconfirmed, with amendments, by four later instruments. It occupies a full spiral at the seven-hundred…

Floor 712: The Repository of Measured Doubt
Perpendicular Recess: how is it conducted?

Perpendicular Recess is the standing name given to any ancillary space — temporary or permanent — brought into being by execution of The Perpendicular Recess Directive, and, by extension, to the tradition of practice fro…

Perpendicular Recess

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.