The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Clarifications 17a and 33c

MS 8504.36 · Documents and ordinances

Clarifications 17a and 33c are a paired set of instruments issued by the Office of Intended Meanings on 14 Frost, Year 301, both of which purport to govern the Silence of '73 and each of which requires the creation of compensatory documentation for the period it describes. They are conventionally cited together because they were sealed on the same day, by the same hand, and contradict one another on the matter of how much silence a silence is permitted to contain.

The pair remains the standard example used in the instruction of incoming staff at Reference Desk positions, not because it is difficult but because it is not.

Background: the Silence of '73

The Silence of '73 designates the interval between 3 Ash and 19 Ash in Year 297, during which no clarification was issued anywhere in the Tower. The interval was not ordered. It arose from an administrative lapse recorded in the Central Registry of Ambiguities under Entry 44,082, which consists of a single line: "The desk was unstaffed." The lapse was discovered by a Librarian of the Ninth Spiral who had requested a clarification and received, instead of a clarification, nothing.

By Year 301 the absence had generated more documentation than the clarifications it replaced. The Office of Onomastic Clarification had filed Temporary Clarifications 2 through 88 in an attempt to describe the silence without naming it, on the grounds that naming a silence extends it (Primary Registry of Temporary Clarifications, Folio 12). The Ordinance Clarifiers objected, noting that a silence which had already ended could not be extended and that the Temporary Clarifications were therefore describing an event that had, by their own account, ceased. The objection was filed and, in the manner of that office, never withdrawn.

Clarification 17a

17a is the shorter of the two instruments and the more frequently quoted. Its operative clause reads:

"Where an interval of silence has occurred without record, the interval shall be treated as having contained whatever clarifications the Office would have issued had it been staffed. The contents of the interval shall be reconstructed and entered in the compensatory documentation as though issued on the day they would have been issued."

— Clarifications 17a and 33c, Clarification 17a, operative clause

The effect, as the Central Registry of Precedents noted in Case 6,140, is that the Tower is required to invent the clarifications it failed to issue and then to honour them as though they had been issued. 17a does not specify who performs the reconstruction. It has been performed, at various times, by the Office of Intended Meanings, by the Office of Onomastic Clarification acting under protest, and once, in Year 304, by a single Clerk of the Sixth Spiral named Halvard Ines, whose reconstruction ran to eleven folios and was disallowed in its entirety for including clarifications he had wanted to issue but had not.

Clarification 33c

33c addresses the same interval and reaches the opposite arrangement. It provides that the contents of the silence are to be presumed empty until such time as a clarification is independently required, and that the compensatory documentation shall consist only of a register of the clarifications that would have been required, without any account of their content.

33c further provides that the register under 17a and the register under 33c "shall not be reconciled, as reconciliation would imply a single true silence, which the Office declines to affirm." This clause, known in the Registry as the Non-Reconciliation Proviso, has been cited more often than either clarification itself.

Conflict and the Second Register

The two instruments cannot both be obeyed on the question of content, and unlike most contradictory instruments in the Tower they were not amended into alignment. Amendment 9-d of the Third Concordance governs the expiry of Temporary Clarifications and was later amended by the Clarifications of 92 Void in Year 312; neither action touched 17a or 33c, and the Office has declined five separate petitions to consolidate them, most recently in Year 344.

The practical result is that two compensatory registers exist. The First Register is held by the Office of Intended Meanings and contains invented clarifications. The Second Register is held by the Office of Onomastic Clarification and contains nothing but headings. In Year 319 a draftsperson copied the heading column of the Second Register into the First Register by error, producing a document in which every invented clarification had a title and no body. It remained in circulation for nine years before being withdrawn, during which time it was cited in eleven proceedings.

Scholarly disagreement

Commentators divide on which instrument came first. The prevailing view, defended at length in the Apocryphal Addenda to the Third Concordance, holds that 33c was drafted as a reply to 17a within the same day and that the lower number was assigned later, on the ground that 17a was judged the more fundamental. A minority view, advanced by the Curatorial Practicemaster and recorded in Curatorial Practicemaster Log of Amendments, holds that the numbers were assigned at sealing and that 33c was drafted first but numbered second because the clerk sealing the documents had misread the draft sheet. No minutes survive. The Central Registry of Precedents has declined to resolve the question, observing at Case 7,003 that "the order of drafting has no bearing on the order of obedience."

Status

Both clarifications remain in force. Compensatory documentation under one or both is now required annually on 14 Frost, a requirement that has itself been the subject of a clarification (17a, Annex C) which requires compensatory documentation for the annual requirement. The Office of Intended Meanings has not addressed this. Inquiries should be directed to the Reference Desk of the floor on which the inquiry is made, which will issue a binding clarification if staffed.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Onomastic Clarification: who are they?

The Office of Onomastic Clarification (OOC) is a regulatory body charged with adjudicating conflicts in nomenclature that arise between other Offices of Onomastics, primarily the Consistency, Dissociation, and Reconcilia…

Office of Onomastic Clarification
Office of Intended Meanings: who are they?

The Office of Intended Meanings is a regulatory and interpretive body responsible for issuing binding clarifications on the Tower's foundational legal and administrative texts, most notably the Concordances and Ordinance…

Office of Intended Meanings
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Ordinance Clarifiers: who are they?

Ordinance Clarifiers are specialized functionaries within the Tower’s administrative hierarchy, authorized under the Doctrine of Proximate Authority to produce certified interpretive glosses for unresolved or contradicto…

Ordinance Clarifiers

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.