Certificates of Jurisdictional Plausibility
MS 9286.97 · Practices and doctrines
The Certificate of Jurisdictional Plausibility is a sealed instrument issued by the Court of Hypothetical Jurisdiction attesting that a ruling body, at the time of its ruling, could plausibly have possessed the authority it exercised. The certificate does not confer jurisdiction, nor restore it, nor declare its absence. It certifies only that the question of jurisdiction is one the Court declines to resolve against the bearer. Certificates are executed in triplicate on laid paper of 90 gsm, of which two copies are retained by the Court and the third is returned to the petitioner, usually after some delay.
The instrument is among the oldest continuously issued documents in the Tower, and the only one whose validity is calculated backward. A certificate issued in the present may validate a ruling made four centuries earlier and, in the same stroke, invalidate any ruling made in reliance upon it between those dates. The Court has never regarded this as a defect. Concordance Addendum 712.Γ, Annex 9, describes retroactive validation as "the ordinary and intended operation of the instrument" (Concordance Addendum 712.Γ, Annex 9).
Form and Endorsements
A complete certificate carries four endorsements, applied in a fixed order that petitioners are frequently surprised to learn is not negotiable. The first records the petitioner's claim; the second records the Court's assessment of that claim under Contextual Plausibility, expressed in Plaurons; the third records the corresponding assessment under Axiomatic Plausibility, expressed in Consilience units; and the fourth is the seal of the issuing bench.
A certificate lacking any endorsement is styled inchoate and has no standing, though it may still be cited in argument, and frequently is. The Office of Latent Properties has complained on eleven recorded occasions that inchoate certificates are admitted in proceedings before it where complete ones would be refused, and has been overruled each time on the ground that an inchoate certificate is not a document but a question.
The physical certificate is folded twice and closed with a wax seal bearing the Court's cipher. Folded certificates are not to be opened on staircases above the fortieth landing, as the draught there has on three occasions separated the seal from the leaf and left the bearer holding an instrument of no evidentiary weight whatsoever.
The Collation Dispute
Since the Plausibility Schism of 712-714, the Court has been divided over whether the two plausibility measures should be collated into a single figure before issue, or reported separately and left to the bearer's use. The collationists hold that a certificate bearing two unmerged figures is not a certificate but a worksheet. The separationists hold that merging them produces a number to which neither measure can be said to consent.
"The Court is not empowered to average two truths in order to produce a third."
— Separationist Memorial, leaf 4, verso
In practice most benches issue both figures and add a marginal note reading uncollated, which satisfies neither party and has done so since 1,148. A proposal to replace the note with a small printed diagram was withdrawn in 1,206 after the diagram was found to resemble the seal too closely and was twice mistaken for it by the registry at Floor 2,211.
Momentum and the Boundaries Problem
Certificates of Jurisdictional Plausibility are not valid where the matter under ruling has acquired irreconcilable momentum. This exclusion was not drafted; it was discovered. In Appeal 9,304, the Momentum Decision, the Court found that a body may hold plausible jurisdiction and nevertheless be unable to exercise it, because the matter before it has begun to move under its own authority and will not consent to be stopped at a boundary. Certificates issued in such cases are recalled and reissued as Certificates of Irreconcilable Momentum.
The decision is widely cited and narrowly understood. Clerks in the issuing registry maintain, without official support, that a certificate is safe to seal so long as the petitioner's matter has not been observed travelling, and the phrase "observed travelling" has entered the registry's working vocabulary without ever having been defined in a Concordance.
Interaction with Dormancy and Stillness
A certificate does not survive the inauguration of Jurisdictional Dormancy. Where a body has received a Certificate of Dormancy from the Office of Latent Properties, any outstanding Certificate of Jurisdictional Plausibility held by that body lapses at once and is returned to the Court, which files it without comment. The lapse is not a revocation and is not recorded as one, a distinction the Office of Latent Properties has twice asked the Court to clarify and twice been told that it is already clear.
Certificates held by bodies that have since received Certificates of Stillness are treated differently: they neither lapse nor remain in force, but are placed in the Suspended Register and may be consulted but not cited. The Register presently contains upward of forty thousand entries, of which perhaps a third have been consulted since deposit.
Notable Recensions and the Grievance of Clerk Adwen Marrow
The certificate's form has been recensed eleven times. The ninth recension, issued in the winter of 1,431, moved the seal from the foot of the leaf to the centre, in the belief that a central seal was harder to detach. The result was that certificates could no longer be folded without creasing the impression, and the tenth recension restored the original position within the year. A small number of ninth-recension certificates remain in circulation and are honoured, though they are kept flat.
Folded and creased certificates aside, the instrument's most persistent critic has been Clerk Adwen Marrow of the issuing registry, who petitioned the Court in 1,442 to add a fifth endorsement recording the time of day at which jurisdiction was exercised. Marrow argued that an authority plausible at noon might not be plausible after vespers, and that the certificate's silence on the point had caused at least four disputes he could name and eleven he could not. The petition was refused on the ground that a certificate records what is plausible, not when. Marrow's objection is preserved in the registry's bound correspondence and is still read aloud, by custom, to each new clerk appointed to the seal desk.
The Court issued 2,904 certificates in the last recorded year, of which 611 were reissued after recall, 88 were withdrawn before sealing, and 14 were, for reasons the ledger does not explain, issued twice to the same petitioner on the same day. Both copies of each are honoured.
See also
See also
-
MS 2342.66
Certificate of Local Calibration
The Certificate of Local Calibration is a single-leaf instrument, sealed in green wax and countersigned by two Librarians, attesti…
-
MS 4676.30
Certificate of Tacit Burden
The Certificate of Tacit Burden is a two-leaf instrument issued by a certified Grievance Auditor attesting that a given quantity o…
-
MS 7633.72
Certificate of Verified Absence
A Certificate of Verified Absence (CVA) is a substrate, issued by the Realized Absence Guild, used as a standard for measuring the…
-
MS 0992.12
Certificates of Chromatic Validity
Certificates of Chromatic Validity are the instruments by which the Central Scriptorium records that a disputed colour has been fo…
-
MS 5963.54
Vertigo Endurance Certification
Vertigo Endurance Certification is a formal designation granted by the Bureau of Hypothetical Durability attesting to an entity's …
-
MS 1393.85
The Doctrine of Latent Jurisdiction
The Doctrine of Latent Jurisdiction is a holding of jurisdictional practice holding that a floor's authority over a matter may exi…
Referenced by
- MS 9871.39 Contextual Plausibility
- MS 8099.32 Plausibility Assessment
Readers also asked
The Momentum Decision (Appeal 9,304): what does it set out?
The Momentum Decision (Appeal 9,304) was a landmark adjudication by the Chamber of Deferred Judgement that formally established procedural momentum as a quantifiable administrative property, later codified in Amendment 4…
The Momentum Decision (Appeal 9,304)Office of Latent Properties: who are they?
Office of Latent Properties was the administrative bureau charged with the official identification, measurement, classification, and containment of latent properties within the Tower from its formation under the Twenty-S…
Office of Latent PropertiesCertificates of Clarified Intent: what is it?
Certificates of Clarified Intent are the sole authorized output of the Refinery of Clarified Intent, located on Fluctuation Floor 44, and the only documentary form the Register of Docketed Intent is permitted to receive.…
Certificates of Clarified IntentJurisdictional Dormancy: how is it conducted?
Passages cited from this record
-
The Court is not empowered to average two truths in order to produce a third.
Separationist Memorial, leaf 4, verso
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6360.55 Floor 2,211
- MS 5075.18 Appeal 9,304
- MS 3561.53 Plaurons
- MS 3556.27 Separationist Memorial
Because you consulted