Category II
MS 1644.51 · Practices and doctrines
Definition and Scope
Category II is the second of the Tower's anomaly classification bands, applied to subjects whose catalogued properties remain internally consistent but whose consistency cannot be verified by any single inspector. The band is administered jointly by the Silent Choirs and the Hall of Procedural Anomalies, an arrangement established under Annex 6 of the Third Concordance and never since revised. The two bodies agree on almost nothing else.
Category II is distinguished from Category III: Operational Anomalies by the requirement of consent. A Category III subject may be documented against its objection, or without its knowledge; a Category II subject must be catalogued in its presence. Where presence cannot be arranged — as in the case of the retroactive holdings — the subject is entered provisionally and marked with a sigil the Office of Taxonomic Reconciliation describes as "pending, with reservation."
The Dialectical Synthesis Provision
The band's most contested clause derives from the annex that accompanied the Great Mending of Floor 90, in which Category II (Dialectical Synthesis) was used to reconcile two irreconcilable inventories of the same staircase. Following the Mending, the procedure was found applicable to any Category II subject whose properties could be argued into a stable pair. The result was temporal drift in a corridor that had previously been stable for four hundred years.
"Where two readings of a Category II subject cannot both be wrong, they are to be treated as both correct and the drift accounted for in the annex."
— Third Concordance, Annex 6, clause 4(b)
The Hall of Procedural Anomalies has since classified Procedural Precession — the tendency of a subject's category to change while the form recording it is being filled in — as Category III, a determination the Silent Choirs reject as Category II. The dispute has run for thirty-one years without adjudication.
The Category 2 Question
A separate and older difficulty concerns the Auditory Proscriptions, a schedule of prohibited sounds drafted in an orthography that renders the band as 'Category 2' rather than 'Category II'. The Catalogical Tribunals have twice declined to settle whether the two designations are variant forms of a single category or two categories that happen to share a numeral. The refusal has been entered as a Standing Precedent without explanation.
The practical consequence is that the Proscriptions cannot be enforced against Category II subjects without renumbering, and renumbering would invalidate the whole schedule. Floor stewards accordingly continue to enforce the Proscriptions against Category 2 subjects only, which in practice means almost none.
Inventory of Registered Category II Holdings
The current register, as maintained by the Silent Choirs at the close of the most recent cycle, lists the following principal holdings:
- The Sigh-Moss of the lower reading rooms, in its reproducing form.
- The Möbius Whisk, filed under Culinary Paradoxes and cross-referenced to Category II by courtesy.
- The standing drift corridor adjacent to Floor 90, pending the disposition of its annex.
- Eleven sound-events listed in the Auditory Proscriptions, held in provisional abeyance.
An earlier register included the ambivalent locales now classified under Category A-ω; they were struck from Category II in the winter of the third recension after a surveyor observed that no locale could be catalogued "in its presence" if its presence could not be fixed.
The Vance Observation
Elara Vance, in the marginalia of her survey of the silence categories, recorded a remark that has since been applied to Category II by extension. She writes that the band "asks the subject to agree to be what it is already being recorded as being," and notes that this is a courtesy rather than a test. The observation is not binding and is cited chiefly by inspectors seeking grounds to waive the presence requirement on the grounds of politeness.
The Metrological Spires have measured the band's stability envelope at 11.4 units on the standard scale, revised downward from 12.0 after the drift corridor incident. The revision stands under objection. Visitors to Category II holdings are asked to leave the door ajar on exit; the moss will not follow, but the register will not close, and an unclosed register must be revisited on the following cycle.
See also
-
MS 2559.73
Department of Cataloguing Consistency
The Department of Cataloguing Consistency is the regulatory and archival authority within the Tower charged with ensuring that all…
-
MS 0505.47
Certificate of Coherence
The Certificate of Coherence is the general instrument by which a subject catalogued in the Tower is declared internally consisten…
-
MS 5929.72
Material Coherence Attestations
Material Coherence Attestations (MCAs) are the primary regulatory instrument for certifying that a holding's physical or logical p…
-
MS 7228.50
Permutation Error
A Permutation Error is a formal classification of procedural anomaly in which the cataloguing or designation of a non-existent sub…
-
MS 6889.36
Bureau of Modal Coherence
The Bureau of Modal Coherence is an administrative body within the Tower responsible for ensuring that catalogued hypotheticals, c…
-
MS 2590.26
Panel for Autochthonous Anomalies
The Panel was constituted in the aftermath of the Aperture Storm incident on Floor 711, during which several catalogued specimens …
Referenced by
- MS 7272.43 Reception Anomaly
- MS 7876.20 Category I
- MS 5608.27 Chief Scriptorial Inspector
Readers also asked
Ambivalent Geometries (Category A-ω): how is it conducted?
Ambivalent Geometries (Category A-ω) is the highest and narrowest classification band in the Tower's scheme for locales whose spatial properties cannot be fixed to a single reading. Where the broader contested geometries…
Ambivalent Geometries (Category A-ω)Office of Taxonomic Reconciliation: who are they?
The Office of Taxonomic Reconciliation is the constituent bureau of the Reconciliation Apparatus charged with the alignment of category to specimen and specimen to category, in that order of priority. It occupies the eas…
Office of Taxonomic ReconciliationStanding Precedent: how is it conducted?
Standing Precedent is a category of authoritative administrative or judicial ruling that remains in continuous legal force until explicitly abrogated, superseded, or rendered obsolete by subsequent concordance. Unlike pr…
Standing PrecedentSigh-Moss: how is it conducted?
Sigh-Moss (officially catalogued under Climatalogical Phenomena, Sub-Category: Atmospheric Biota, Designation CP/AB-7) is an airborne, sporulating lichen analog documented exclusively within the controlled archival envir…
Sigh-MossPassages cited from this record
-
Where two readings of a Category II subject cannot both be wrong, they are to be treated as both correct and the drift accounted for in the annex.
Third Concordance, Annex 6, clause 4(b)
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3055.36 Auditory Proscriptions
Because you consulted