The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Bulletin of Integrative Empty Spaces

MS 4269.08 · Practices and doctrines

Bulletin of Integrative Empty Spaces

The Bulletin of Integrative Empty Spaces is the quarterly gazette of the Annexationist School, issued from the Scriptorium of Standing Reserves on Floor 318b and distributed, by long-standing arrangement, to every floor whose number contains the digit 8. It records newly integrated volumes, corrigenda to the Integrative Function registers, and the standing disputes arising from Regulation 8 and its many recensions. It should not be confused with Bulletin of Botanical Accord, whose title differs by a single word and whose readership, according to the Registrar of Subscriptions, "overlaps only in the person of Librarian Ovescu, who receives both and reads neither in full."

History and Mandate

The Bulletin was first issued in the winter of the year the Tower records as 1,146 Post-Concordance, six years after the compilation of the Manual of Integrative Empty Spaces. Its founding mandate, restated in every masthead, is "to publish the whole count of empty volumes formally annexed in the preceding quarter, without preference, without summary, and without conclusion." This last prohibition has been tested more than once. In 1,209 P.C. an editor appended a brief interpretive preface to the quarterly count; the preface was struck from the record by Concordance 41, which holds that "a gazette of volumes may not itself occupy a position." The editor, whose name the Bulletin declines to print, is referred to in the School's internal correspondence only as "the occupant."

Contents and Formatting

Each issue runs to forty-eight pages, of which thirty-nine are the count proper: a columnar list of floor numbers, spiral markings, aperture designations, and the date on which each volume was folded into its host floor's record. The remaining nine pages carry corrigenda, notices of disputed annexations, and an obituary section for Librarians who have died without being publicly named, which in practice consists of blank ruled lines in a fixed number. Librarian Petrov-Haas has argued in the Proceedings of the Standing Committee on Null Volumes that this section is "the most honest page in the Tower," though she has not explained in what sense.

The count is printed in a single column, never two, following Treatise IX of the Manual, which holds that a space may not testify to its own occupancy. The Bulletin's compositors interpret this to mean that no annexed volume may appear beside another on the same line, "lest the two bear witness to each other." The resulting pages are narrow and much-whited, and the Guild of Paper Factors has twice petitioned for a wider format without success.

The Dispute Over Null-Glove Reporting

Since 1,317 P.C. the Bulletin has also carried a supplementary schedule of volumes annexed under Procedural Bulletin 88, the protocol governing Null-Gloves. The schedule is printed on grey stock and bound at the back, and its status is contested. The Registry of Occupied Volumes maintains that grey-stock entries are operational records and fall under Registry's Standard Practice Bulletin 447, Clause 12, and therefore may not be cited as precedent. The School maintains the opposite, citing Ordinance 7, which formally distinguishes the Integrative Function from SFU-D and, the School argues, leaves glove-annexations squarely within the Bulletin's founding mandate.

"The grey pages are part of the Bulletin or they are not. If they are, the Registry must accept them as precedent. If they are not, the Bulletin has been publishing forty-eight pages of which nine do not exist, and the compositors would like to know which nine."

— Librarian Petrov-Haas, Proceedings of the Standing Committee on Null Volumes, vol. 14

The Sixty-Third Concordance appears to settle the matter in the Registry's favour, but its fourth annex was itself amended twice before ratification and the amended text omits the word "precedent" entirely. Concordance 88, issued the same season, contradicts it without acknowledging it. Both remain in force.

Notable Issues

The issue of the third quarter, 1,402 P.C., is the only one ever withdrawn. It listed an annexation on the Seventy-Second Floor that the floor's own Administrative Bulletin 704-b had already recorded as never having occurred. The Bulletin's editor at the time, Librarian Anselm Roe, declined to reprint and declined to retract, and the resulting gap in the run is preserved in the Scriptorium of Standing Reserves with a slip reading only "see 704-b." Collectors regard the withdrawn issue as the most valuable object in the Tower that cannot be obtained, a distinction it shares with several others.

The issue of the first quarter, 1,388 P.C., carried the first published reference to the Problem of Empty Floors in its corrigenda section, in a note of two lines whose author is given as "a Correspondent." The Correspondents of the Empty Shelf have claimed authorship collectively ever since, without producing the manuscript.

Scholarly Disagreement

There is no consensus on what the Bulletin is for. Librarian Ovescu treats it as an administrative instrument, and has noted that "the Bulletin's count and the Registry's count have not agreed in any quarter since 1,344, and both offices regard the other's figure as the error." Librarian Anselm Roe, by contrast, holds in the Proceedings of the Standing Committee on Null Volumes that the Bulletin is a work of record in the archival sense and that its proper reader is not the administrator but "the person who wishes to know what has been folded away and by whom, and who does not intend to do anything about it." The 704-b affair is cited by both sides, apparently without embarrassment.

Subscriptions are renewed annually and are not transferable. Readers who miss an issue may consult the standing copy in the Scriptorium; the standing copy may not be removed from the reading room, and the reading room closes at the hour the lamps are trimmed, which varies by floor and is posted at the door.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Regulation 8: what does it set out?

Regulation 8, formally titled "On the Precedence of Null Volumes," is a foundational piece of administrative law within the Tower, governing the conditions under which an empty or theoretically vacant space may be design…

Regulation 8
Annexationist School: how is it conducted?

The School formally organized in Year 341, following the resolution of the Dispute of the Adjacent Voids on Floor 17. The ruling by the Librarian-Adjudicator established a precedent that "proximate absences may be treate…

Annexationist School
Registry's Standard Practice Bulletin 447: how is it conducted?

Standard Practice Bulletin 447 was issued by the Bureau of Registry’s Office of Procedural Integrity on 17 Scribe’s Rest, 04-77α (Tower Standard Chronology). Its mandate, as stated in its preamble, is to "codify the mome…

Registry's Standard Practice Bulletin 447
Bulletin of Botanical Accord: what does it set out?

The Bulletin of Botanical Accord is the sole instrument by which rulings of the Office of Botanical Concordance attain full concordant force. It is issued at irregular intervals from the Concordance scriptorium on Floor …

Bulletin of Botanical Accord

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.