The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Aural Null-Spaces

MS 3575.72 · Practices and doctrines

The term Aural Null-Spaces designates those volumetrically enclosed regions of the Tower in which sound neither propagates nor decays, but is held — for want of a better verb — in abeyance. An aural null-space is not silent in the ordinary sense. A silent room absorbs sound; an aural null-space returns it to a condition that the Aural Maintenance Code describes, at Clause 12(iv), as "prior to utterance and subsequent to it simultaneously." Standing inside one is reported to be unremarkable until the occupant attempts to speak, at which point the attempt is registered only as a pressure behind the sternum.

Since the Committee for Aural Integrity assumed jurisdiction over all abeyant acoustic conditions in the winter of the year the archive records as 4409, aural null-spaces have been counted, mapped, and — in fourteen contested instances — decommissioned. The count currently stands at 2,317 confirmed volumes, of which 211 are under appeal.

Definition and classification

The Committee's working definition requires four conditions: enclosure on at least five faces; an interior volume exceeding nine cubic cubits; a measured reverberation time of precisely zero; and the persistence of the null condition for longer than the interval between two strikes of the Diffraction Scanner calibration bell, which is forty-one seconds. Regions failing the fourth condition are classified as transient aural lacunae and are not entered in the register, though they are logged separately by the Aural Lacunae Archive.

A persistent source of friction is the status of spaces that are aurally null but not volumetrically enclosed — open landings, for example, and the long gallery above the Floor ǂ stairhead. The Guild of Null-Techs holds that the enclosure condition is a relic of the Aural Cadre's early annotations and has no force; the Committee has declined four times to strike it. The Stanton Aural Grid cannot presently be extended to open volumes, which the Committee cites as evidence that open nullity is unmeasurable and therefore, by Clause 30, unclassifiable.

Detection and survey

Aural null-spaces are located by a procedure the surveyors call walking the hum: a technician carrying a struck tuning fork proceeds along a corridor until the fork's tone ceases between two paces, then recedes until it resumes. The interval between those points is recorded as the space's approach margin. Margins vary from under a cubit to the celebrated case of the eastern vestibule on Floor 4402, where the approach margin is reported at thirty-one paces and has swallowed three surveyors' forks, which were never recovered and are not thought to have fallen.

Triangulation against the Stanton Aural Grid was attempted during the Aural Lattice Initiative, and the results remain the most complete survey of null volumes on record. The Committee has never certified them. Its stated reason is a discrepancy of eleven per cent between the Grid's figures and those obtained by fork-walking, and its unstated reason is generally understood to be that the Grid survey was conducted by the Guild of Vacant Spaces, whose methods the Committee does not recognize under Regulation 8.

The Hollow Registry dispute

The Hollow Registry is the register of aural null-spaces maintained since 4411 by the Committee's Sub-Office of Abeyant Volumes. It is not the only such register. The Guild of Vacant Spaces maintains its own list, compiled under the precedence doctrine of Regulation 8, and the two lists have disagreed on the number of null-spaces since the second year of either's existence. In 4416 the discrepancy stood at 114 volumes; in 4429 it stood at 114 volumes. Neither office will explain the coincidence, and the Concordance of Registers forbids the two lists being laid side by side on the same table.

"The null volume is prior to its occupant, prior to its measurement, and prior to the office that would measure it. A register of such volumes is therefore a register of the registrant."

— Regulation 8, Preamble

The Committee's rejoinder, drafted by the then-clerk Aurelia Vantt and appended to the 4416 Hollow Registry as a note, is a single sentence: "The Preamble is not the Regulation." Vantt's note was itself disputed for sixty years, on the grounds that a note appended to a registry is not part of the registry; the dispute was resolved in 4476 in favour of the note's inclusion, whereupon Vantt's successor requested its removal. Both requests remain live.

Occupancy and the question of harm

No occupant of a confirmed aural null-space has ever reported hearing anything within it, and this uniformity is the chief argument against their harm. The Committee's standing position, stated in its bulletin of 4441, is that a null-space "cannot injure what it does not admit," a formulation the Guild of Null-Techs has challenged on the grounds that three of the four surveyors who established the Floor 4402 vestibule's approach margin subsequently declined to speak in any room containing a clock. The Committee has classified these abstentions as unrelated.

Access is governed by permit. A visitor entering a confirmed null-space must be accompanied by a second person who remains outside it and who is required to speak continuously for the duration of the visit. The requirement is practical: the companion's voice is the only means by which the visitor's return to ordinary air can be timed. Visitors are asked not to bring tuning forks. Fourteen forks are held in the Committee's evidence cabinet on Floor 9090, awaiting return to owners who have not come forward.

The decommissioned volumes

Of the fourteen aural null-spaces formally decommissioned, eleven were closed by the installation of Aural Dampeners in reverse configuration, a procedure the Committee authorized in 4438 over the objection of the Aural Lacunae Archive, which argued that a null-space is a holding and not a fault. The three remaining decommissions were accomplished by the simpler method of removing a door and leaving it open; in each case the null condition lapsed within a day, and in one case within an hour, prompting a further dispute as to whether the space had ever met the enclosure condition at all.

The Archive's objection was entered as a formal dissent and has never been withdrawn. Its author, the archivist Meren Cald, is recorded in the Archive's minute-book as having stated at the close of the hearing that the Committee had "decommissioned a room by opening it, which is not decommissioning but weather." The minute-book gives no reply.

Open questions

Two matters remain before the Committee. The first is whether aural null-spaces are subject to the census required by Directive 19-C: Mandatory Auditory Census of Silent Spaces, which was drafted for acoustically null environments and has been read by some officers to exclude abeyant ones. The second is whether the spaces may be used as calibration volumes for the Aural Diffraction Scanner (SMP-Δ), a proposal that would replace the quarterly recourse to the Archival Null Chamber on Floor 9090 and that has been pending since 4452. The Scanner's custodians have asked, reasonably, what the Scanner would measure in a space where nothing propagates. No answer has been minuted.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Aural Dampeners: what is it for?

Aural Dampeners are architectural installations or portable devices designed to suppress, contain, or redirect anomalous or non-conformant sound phenomena within the Tower. Their primary function is to prevent undesired …

Aural Dampeners
Stanton Aural Grid: what is it for?

Stanton Aural Grid refers to the permanent installation of 1,244 omnidirectional contact microphones arranged in a hexagonal lattice across the southern quadrant of The Observational Grid on Seventy-Second Floor. Adminis…

Stanton Aural Grid
Non-Spaces of Floor ǂ: where is it?

The Non-Spaces of Floor ǂ are the seventeen documented regions of Floor ǂ (pronounced, by standing instruction of the Office of Floor Designation, as "Floor Null-Double-Bar") in which no measurement taken by any instrume…

Non-Spaces of Floor ǂ
Regulation 8: what does it set out?

Regulation 8, formally titled "On the Precedence of Null Volumes," is a foundational piece of administrative law within the Tower, governing the conditions under which an empty or theoretically vacant space may be design…

Regulation 8

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.