The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Attributed Scribe

MS 9262.54 · Practices and doctrines

The Attributed Scribe is a clerical designation, not a rank, applied to any scribe whose hand cannot be shown to be present in the work ascribed to them. The category is administrative rather than honorific, and it carries neither stipend nor precedence; its holder appears in the rolls, is counted for quorum, and is otherwise treated as absent. The distinction matters chiefly in disputes, where an Attributed Scribe is competent to receive a citation but not to answer one.

Approximately one in nine entries in the Scribe Clerical Grade register bears the attribution mark, a hollow sigma set after the name and filled in only upon production of a signed hand-sample. The fillings are rare. As of the last complete reckoning, four hundred and six hollow sigmas remained unfilled on the upper spirals, and two scribes had been marked in the same decade for the same treatise, neither of whom could be located to be told so.

Origin and the Valerius Ruling

The designation is generally traced to the Ninety-Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, which provided that "where a work is ascribed and no hand is present, the ascription shall be entered against the name, and the name shall not be entered against the hand." The wording was drafted to resolve a dispute over the compilation of the Ledger of Sealed Declarations, in which three separate scribes had each been credited with the same folio on the strength of three separate marginal notes, none of them in the folio itself.

The ruling's practical effect was immediate and unintended. Scribes with strong claims to authorship — that is, those who had demonstrably written the thing — found themselves classed as ordinary scribes and therefore answerable for errors in work they had written; scribes with no claims at all found themselves classed as Attributed and therefore unanswerable for anything. Within two generations the hollow sigma had become, in the words of one later commentator, "the safest mark a careless scribe can wear."

"An attribution answers the question of the name. It does not answer the question of the hand, and it must not be permitted to seem to."

— Principles of Vertical Integration, Annex B, quoting Librarian-Scribe Valerius

The School of the Unnamed Scribe and the De-attribution Campaign

No body has pressed harder against the designation than the School of the Unnamed Scribe, whose principal grievance is that the Attributed class preserves names that the evidence no longer supports. The School's campaign to de-attribute the works of Librarian-Scribe Anselm the Circumspect proceeded on exactly this ground: if no hand survives, the School argued, the name should be withdrawn to the margin and the folio re-entered as anonymous. The Seventeenth Recension of the Concordance of Hands eventually permitted the marginal withdrawal, but it did so without disturbing the hollow sigma, so that Anselm's name was removed from the body of the text and simultaneously retained in the attribution column. Both entries remain current.

The School has made the same argument four times since, and lost the same way each time. Its standing complaint, entered by the de-attribution advocate Scribe Yellin of the Sixth Spiral in Year 61, is that the designation "confers the appearance of authorship upon those who have earned only the appearance of a name," a formulation the Librarians have never troubled to answer.

The Hollow Sigma Dispute

A sustained scholarly disagreement concerns whether the hollow sigma may be filled retrospectively at all. The strict reading, associated with the Office of Hand-Samples and set out in its circular of Year 88, holds that a filled sigma asserts a continuous chain of custody from hand to attribution, and that no such chain may be asserted after the death of the scribe, the loss of the exemplar, or the closure of the spiral in which the work was examined — whichever came first. The permissive reading, urged by the Bureau of Attributed Mention and adopted informally on Floors 400 through 800, holds that a sigma may be filled at any time by any clerk with access to a plausible sample, since the purpose of filling is not proof but the tidying of the register.

Filling is generally performed in the spring, when the register is reconciled and the ink stores are opened for the annual audit. Scribes are asked not to fill sigmas in red.

The dispute has produced at least one recorded casualty. In the winter of Year 112, a clerk of the Bureau, Clerk Adanel of the Reconciliation Desk, filled forty-one sigma marks on Floors 812-C and 813-C using samples drawn from a single convenient hand, and then discovered that the hand belonged to a living scribe who had been dead in the register for sixty years. Adanel's correction was accepted; the six weeks of correspondence establishing that the scribe had never existed in the first place were not, and remain unread in the Bureau's third annex.

Attributed Scribes in Practice

The designation is most often encountered on floor-inventories and shelf-lists, where it functions as a caution rather than a credit. A volume whose compiler is styled Attributed Scribe may be consulted freely, but may not be cited in support of a claim about the compiler's opinions, habits, errors, or intentions — a prohibition the Scribe-Adjudicator enforces by striking the offending citation from the record and entering the strike in the record.

A small number of Attributed Scribes have nonetheless acquired reputations, generally against their will. The name of Halven Marrow appears as Attributed Scribe on eleven shelf-lists, which the School of the Unnamed Scribe cites as proof that no such person wrote them and the Bureau cites as proof that someone did. The designation has also been applied posthumously to Vell of the Narrow Stair on Floor 119-β, an application that the Office of Hand-Samples regards as improper and the Bureau regards as complete.

Recorded Objects

The following items are currently held under the hollow sigma, each awaiting a hand-sample that the Office of Hand-Samples has not yet been able to collect:

None of the three has been produced for examination since Year 104. The Office of Hand-Samples has requested them annually; the Bureau has declined annually, on the ground that a sample cannot be taken from an object whose hand is the matter in dispute.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Scribe-Adjudicator: how is it conducted?

Scribe-Adjudicator is a specialized judicial rank within the administrative hierarchy of the Tower, designating a Scribe who has been vested with provisional authority to interpret and apply the Concordances within their…

Scribe-Adjudicator
Seventy-First Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventy-First Concordance is the seventy-first of the numbered Concordances, ratified on 14 Ember 2 by the Board of Concordant Interpretation and sealed with the black seal of the Librarian chapter at Seventy-First L…

Seventy-First Concordance
Librarian-Scribe Anselm the Circumspect: who were they?

Librarian-Scribe Anselm the Circumspect (fl. late 14-Δ period) was a junior scribe within the Tower Archives whose primary legacy lies in contested attributions surrounding key amendments to the Concordances. His precise…

Librarian-Scribe Anselm the Circumspect
Scribe Clerical Grade: how is it conducted?

Scribe Clerical Grade is the ordinal designation applied to clerical personnel within the Tower's service hierarchy, ranging from Scribe-Provisional at the ungraded foot to Scribe-Adjudicator at the seventh and presently…

Scribe Clerical Grade

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.