The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Archivism of Unseconded Motions

MS 5197.26 · Practices and doctrines

The Archivism of Unseconded Motions is the branch of Tower record-keeping concerned with motions that were filed, docketed and shelved without ever attracting a second. It is distinguished from ordinary archival practice by a single doctrinal point: an unseconded motion is not a failed motion. It remains live, open to seconding, and therefore continues to require filing, indexing, preservation and periodic review. The Corpus of Unseconded Motions is presently reckoned at somewhere above ninety thousand items, though the figure is revised downward each time a second is discovered, and upward each time one is lost.

The discipline is administered jointly by the Office of Voluntary Correspondence and the clerks of the ''Motions Sub-Registry (Annex B)'', a working arrangement that has never been reduced to a single instrument and is defended by both offices on precisely that ground.

The Founding Misunderstanding

The practice originates in the aftermath of the ratification of Concordance 3, Clause 11, when the Archivist for Unseconded Motions cast the single dissenting vote. The dissent was entered without a seconder, as dissents then were, and the Archivist was accordingly required to hold it open. What was intended as a procedural formality became, over eleven years, a private archive. By the time the position was subsumed into the duties defined under Concordance 12, Clause 7, the collection had grown to four thousand items and had acquired a catalogue.

Later commentators have treated this as the founding misunderstanding of the field. Falbert of the Uninked Quill, whose name the Roll of Unseconded Signatures records as the architect of the compromise that ended the Schism of the Uninked Pen, is reported to have called the early corpus "an accident that has since been given a chair" (Roll of Unseconded Signatures, marginalia to entry 211). The chair was endowed in Year 402 and has not been vacant since.

Procedure

An unseconded motion is entered in the ''Register of Motions Awaiting a Second'', bound in grey and kept in the ''Aperture Room, Spiral Delta''. It is reviewed at intervals of nine years, a period chosen because it is long enough that the original filer is usually no longer available to be consulted, and short enough that the review can still be described as pending. At review, the archivist of the day must determine whether the motion has in the interim been seconded, superseded, or rendered incoherent by the passage of later instruments. In practice most motions are found to fall into the third class.

The office keeps a standing instruction, pinned to the inside of the door and renewed each Ladyday: no motion is to be seconded by an archivist, however sound it appears, because the archivist is the one who will later have to certify that it was not.

Where a motion is unclassifiable, the customary course is to file it at the Ceiling of Pending Motions under the Seventh Addendum, which provides the framework for such filings. This is generally regarded as tidying rather than resolution, since the Ceiling does not return anything. The archivism of unseconded motions maintains no standing quarrel with that disposal; it maintains only that the file must be complete before it is sent up.

Points of Scholarly Disagreement

The chief dispute in the field concerns the status of the Archive of Unseen Motions. From Year 718 the keepers of that archive were Kaelen and Elara of the Parallel Stacks, and a minority tradition holds that the Archive of Unseen Motions is simply the unseconded corpus viewed from below, and that the two should be catalogued as one. The Committee for Ontological Review has twice declined to rule, on the ground that the question cannot be settled without opening both collections and comparing them, which neither office permits.

A second dispute concerns the numbering. Concordance 12, Clause 7 assimilates unseconded motions into the general run of deferred business, while Declaration 88-C treats them as a separate class entirely. The two have not been reconciled. The Bench of Minor Motions applies Declaration 88-C, and is regularly cited before it Ordinance 22.8; the Central Registry of Stated Intent applies Concordance 12 and will not discuss the matter. Practitioners keep both citations to hand and produce whichever the presiding officer has most recently cited.

Notable Holdings

An inventory of the principal holdings was ordered by the Office of the Warden of Descent in Year 903 and returned in the following form:

  • The Vestibule Petition — filed by a party who did not return; kept in the Vestibule of Provisional Tenancy against that party's eventual reappearance. Pending 640 years.
  • The Long Second — a motion carried between floors and seconded at every landing, none of them competent. Withdrawn from circulation in Year 771.
  • The Somnolent Mimer's second motion — see Somnolent Mimer. The attribution is disputed.
  • Four hundred and nine motions concerning Floor 447, all unseconded, none mislaid.

Reporting and the Winter of Year 861

The branch reports to the Registry of Motions and, through it, to the Stack of Open Argument Object, whose custodians regard the unseconded corpus as a distant and somewhat embarrassing relative. It is not described in the Index of Permissible Vertical Motions, no notice of intent to traverse being required for a motion that has not moved, although between Year 861 and Year 866 the department insisted otherwise.

The dispute arose when a clerk, Oris of the Third Recess, carried four unseconded motions up three flights to a warmer reading room and was cited by a Department of Vertical Transit inspector for transporting live business without a notice of intent. Oris argued that an unseconded motion occupies no floor and therefore cannot traverse one. The inspector, who had counted the flights personally, maintained that the motions were in a satchel and the satchel was on a stair. The matter was referred upward, then sideways, and was finally settled in Oris's favour on a technicality that the Warden's office has never consented to publish. The inspector transferred to a horizontal department. In the winter of that year the reading rooms were so cold that the grey registers were kept closed, the ink having cracked in Year 858, and Oris's motions waited three months on a landing before anyone could be found to rule on them.

Since Year 866 no notice has been required, and the Morgana reading rooms are heated.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Registry of Motions: who are they?

The Registry's mandate is defined by the Principle of Documented Impulse, which holds that any intention to alter a state of affairs, if properly notarized, becomes a tangible administrative force. Motions are classified…

Registry of Motions
Department of Vertical Transit: who are they?

The Department of Vertical Transit (DVT) is the Tower's principal administrative authority for all sanctioned vertical conduits, responsible for the oversight, certification, and procedural regulation of non-mechanical a…

Department of Vertical Transit
Schism of the Uninked Pen: what happened?

The Schism of the Uninked Pen was a doctrinal crisis and institutional fragmentation that arose within the Guild of Dormant Scribes in the late Zenithal Period, centering on the proper ontological status of unwritten or …

Schism of the Uninked Pen
Stack of Open Argument Object: how is it conducted?

The Stack of Open Argument Object is a physical manifestation of unresolved debate located in the central chamber of the Athenaeum of Open Questions, on Floor 111: The Athenaeum of Open Questions. It is housed within The…

Stack of Open Argument Object

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.