Annex of Tangible Proof
MS 9070.82 · Practices and doctrines
The Annex of Tangible Proof is the standing deposit of physical evidence admitted to substantiate claims otherwise unsupported by documentation, and the only floor of the Tower whose holdings are weighed rather than catalogued. It occupies Floors 721 through 728 of the western riser and is administered jointly by the Bureau of Tangible Administration and the Archivists of Tangible Ephemera, an arrangement that has produced four centuries of quiet jurisdictional resentment and one locked cabinet that no one will claim.
The Annex does not hold proofs in the sense current in the upper floors, where Cross-Referencing as Proof is accepted as sufficient. It holds the objects that proofs are made from: a jar of settled dust from a floor that has since been renumbered, the original swatch against which a colour dispute was settled in 1304, the particular stone whose weight settled the question of the Third Proof of Garmon before the Symposium of the Damp Proof was asked to rule on whether it should have.
History and Establishment
The Annex was constituted by the Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, which observed that certain claims "cannot be proved by writing, and must therefore be proved by weight, and must therefore be weighed somewhere, and that somewhere is not the reading room." The clause is generally read as an instruction; the Bureau has always read it as a complaint.
Its first keeper, the clerk Avenel of the Low Register, took up the post in the winter of that same year and spent eleven months cataloguing nothing, on the grounds that the first deposit — a sealed jar of dust — had not yet been weighed, and could not be weighed until a scale was procured, and no scale could be procured until the Annex had a budget, and the budget required a register of holdings. The jar was eventually weighed in the twelfth month. Its mass has been disputed ever since.
The present keeper is Orra Vintle, who holds the post in reversion and has not been confirmed. She keeps the registers anyway. It is not clear who could confirm her.
Procedure and the Tangible Precedence
Deposits are admitted under the Doctrine of Tangible Precedence, which holds that an object, once admitted and weighed, takes precedence over any document describing it, including the document of deposit. This is a stronger rule than most floors are comfortable with. The Manual of Tangible Progress codifies the doctrine at Chapter 11 and provides, at 11.7, for the "stabilization module" — the standard sequence by which an Archivist of Tangible Ephemera secures an object against decay, mislabelling, and the attentions of visitors.
The sequence runs to nine stages and has never been completed on a living deposit. Stage six requires the object to be weighed twice, once in the presence of the depositor and once in the presence of a witness who has never seen it. There is one such witness presently on the floor. She is ninety-one and has been kept from the eastern cases for that reason.
"Where an object and its description disagree, the object shall be weighed, and the description corrected to the object's weight."
— Manual of Tangible Progress, Chapter 11, clause 11.4
Visitors are required to declare any loose stones before entering the western cases. This is stated on the door and enforced without exception.
The Vintle Recension and the Two Registers
Orra Vintle's tenure has produced the dispute for which the Annex is now best known. Sometime before 1402 she began a second register, on the reasoning that the first register recorded what had been deposited and the second recorded what had been weighed, and that the two had begun to diverge. By her count, fourteen objects in the eastern cases had been weighed but never deposited, and three had been deposited twice under different names.
The Bureau of Tangible Records objected that a second register was a recension of the first, and that recensions of Bureau registers require a Concordance citation, which Vintle did not produce. The Materials Board took the opposite view, holding in an advisory opinion of 1403 that a register of weights is not a register of holdings and therefore falls under the Annex's own competence. Neither body has withdrawn its position. Both are cited on the door.
Holdings of Note
The annex's principal deposits are few and enormous:
- The Settled Dust (Floor 721, Case 1) — sealed, weighed annually, unopened since deposit.
- The Colour Swatch of 1304 (Floor 723) — the last surviving swatch of its dye lot.
- The Garmon Stone (Floor 725) — weight recorded; the record of the weight is missing.
- The Locked Cabinet (Floor 728) — contents unknown; keys held by two offices, neither of which will send them.
The stone is the difficulty. It was admitted to settle the Third Proof of Garmon, was weighed by Avenel of the Low Register in the presence of the depositor, and was returned to its case. The weight was entered on a slip, the slip was filed, and the file has since been found to contain a slip recording a different weight with the same ink and the same hand. Neither the Bureau nor the Archivist has been willing to re-weigh the stone, on the grounds that a re-weighing would constitute a new proof, and the Annex does not make proofs; it holds them.
Relation to the Upper Floors
Why the Annex sits at 721 while the reading rooms that cite it lie above Floor 900 has never been explained. The Echo-Stratifications of the western riser show that the number was assigned during a period of extensive renumbering and may reflect nothing. The Hum of Continuity Document records a low tone audible in the Annex on still days, which the Archivist attributes to the ventilation shaft and the Bureau attributes to the dust.
The Annex is not a proving floor. The The Chamber of Axiomatic Proof on the eastern riser proves; the Annex weighs. Whether a thing weighed is a thing proved was settled, for administrative purposes, by the doctrine of the self-evident, which the Annex cites in its own defence and the Chamber does not accept.
See also
-
MS 1869.26
Writ of Tangible Ingress
The Writ of Tangible Ingress is the instrument by which the Tower authorizes an entity that is not yet catalogued to be catalogued…
-
MS 7622.16
Floor 308
Floor 308, officially catalogued as the Observatorium of Errant Postulate, is a mid-tier scholastic and verification floor special…
-
MS 4732.38
Observatorium of Errant Postulate
Observatorium of Errant Postulate is the official catalogued name of Floor 308, a mid-tier scholastic and verification floor devot…
-
MS 1824.57
Physical Manifestation
Physical manifestation is the process by which a conceptual, abstract, or procedural principle is granted a tangible, spatial, and…
-
MS 7665.26
Specimen Couriers
Specimen Couriers refers to the specialized division within the Couriers of the Silent Stair charged with the physical transport a…
-
MS 5255.08
Documentation Freeze
The Documentation Freeze is a standing condition of the Tower's records in which all further documentation concerning a given matt…
Referenced by
- MS 2550.45 Guild of Fundamental Mechanics
Readers also asked
Bureau of Tangible Records: how is it conducted?
The Bureau of Tangible Records is the sub-bureau of the Upper Administration charged with the custody, authentication, and physical stabilisation of records whose subject is a material object. It is often confused with t…
Bureau of Tangible RecordsCross-Referencing as Proof: what is it?
Cross-Referencing as Proof is a evidentiary doctrine holding that a reference which survives independent re-indexing may be admitted as sufficient demonstration of the proposition it connects. It is distinct from, and pr…
Cross-Referencing as ProofArchivists of Tangible Ephemera: how is it conducted?
The role was formally instantiated by Ordinance 899 in Cycle 142, following the protracted classification dispute over the holdings of Floor 7,402, "The Gallery of Fading Postulates." The Archivists of Tangible Ephemera …
Archivists of Tangible EphemeraNinth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …
Ninth ConcordancePassages cited from this record
-
Where an object and its description disagree, the object shall be weighed, and the description corrected to the object's weight.
Manual of Tangible Progress, Chapter 11, clause 11.4
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 8133.72 Orra Vintle
- MS 4167.04 Avenel of the Low Register
Because you consulted