Amendment Sigma-9 to Concordance 7,022
MS 4917.37 · Documents and ordinances
Amendment Sigma-9 to Concordance 7,022 is the instrument by which the Seventh Concordance — itself a document whose existence is attested only through the amendment now under discussion — was brought into alignment with the sigma-classification scheme, and the immediate cause of the Sigma Cascade Principle's first recorded invocation. It occupies eleven folios in the Sub-Registrar's hand and is held to be the only amendment in the archive whose own authority is among the matters it amends. Clerks refer to it, when they must refer to it at all, as "the Nine."
Text and structure
The Nine is arranged in four recensions, of which the second is missing and the third is missing only in part. Folios 1 through 3 establish that every provision of Concordance 7,022 bearing a sigma designation shall be read as bearing it twice; folios 4 through 8 set out which provisions those are, in a schedule that refers the reader forward to folios 9 through 11, which in turn refer the reader back to folios 1 through 3. No provision of the amendment has been found to terminate in a substantive rule. The Sub-Registrar's marginal note at folio 6 reads, in full:
"The reader who has arrived here has done what was asked of him. Nothing further is asked."
— Amendment Sigma-9, folio 6, marginal note, hand of the Sub-Registrar
Folio 11, the last, bears the seal of the Concordance Amendment Tracking office and a certificate of receipt dated 14 Ventose, Year 398, though the office's own ledger records no accession on that date and the clerk who signed is not listed on any staff roll of the period.
The Year 398 dispute
Within a fortnight of the Nine's circulation, the Office of Final Accord — established under the Fourth Concordance's Amendment Sigma for the issuance of Certificates of Final Form — declined to certify the amendment on the ground that it could not be certified until it had been certified. A counter-motion from the Sub-Registrar's clerks argued that the Accord's refusal was itself a final form and might therefore be certified independently, which would leave the Nine certified in effect if not in name. The Accord answered that a refusal is only final once certified, and that the certification of the refusal was pending the certification of the Nine.
Matters stood so for eleven days. On the twelfth, the Doctrine of Administrative Silence was raised from the floor and the question lapsed. The Nine has remained in force and uncertified ever since. It is the only such instrument in the tracking register, and the register marks it with a dagger.
Invocation against Blueprint Sigma-9
In the winter of Year 404 a proposed amendment to Blueprint Sigma-9 (Recursive) was tabled that would have required the blueprint to describe itself in the schedule of its own components. Objection was raised that the proposal was neither more nor less than the Nine in new drafting, and that to adopt it would be to adopt the Nine a second time without the certification the Accord had withheld. The Sigma Cascade Principle was invoked, on the reasoning that a sigma instrument applied to a sigma instrument must either terminate or recurse, and that the archive had already ruled out the first.
The invocation succeeded. The amendment to the blueprint was struck, and the Nine was read into the record as the governing text by reference — an outcome its own supporters had not sought and, on the Accord's account, could not lawfully have obtained. A note appended to Material Filing Sigma-9 observes that the principle worked "in the manner of a door that will not close because it is already ajar" (Material Filing Sigma-9, Appendix C).
Scholarly disagreement
The central dispute concerns whether Concordance 7,022 has any independent existence. The majority position, held by the Sub-Registrar's office, is that it does not and never did, and that the Seven Thousand Series is a numbering reserve entered prospectively so that later instruments might cite into it without amendment. On this reading the Nine amends nothing whatsoever, and its durability is a function of the archive's reluctance to delete a number once issued.
A minority, associated with the readers of the Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7, maintains that Concordance 7,022 is an ordinary concordance of the middle period, suppressed in Year 361 along with its companion volumes, and that the Nine is a surviving fragment of the suppression's paperwork rather than a true amendment. This view accounts for the missing recension and for the Accord's insistence that the document it was asked to certify was not the document before it, but requires the suppression to have gone unrecorded in the Concordance Amendment Tracking, which is a difficult thing to arrange and, the Sub-Registrar's office notes drily, has never been attempted.
A third and increasingly cited comment, from the reader assigned to the Nine in Year 431, declines to take a position and instead records that the folios smell faintly of lamp oil and that the binding was renewed in Year 403, when no renewal of the Nine is entered in the bindery's books.
Shelf conditions and handling
The Nine is shelved in the Seven Thousand bay, third press, at a height of 1.4 metres, between a gap and a gap. Under the Third Concordance's Amendment 14-f it must be read under a sigma-rated resonance scanner where the bay's geometry is in doubt, which at the third press it is. The scanner's own calibration draws on the Clarified Chromatic Scale, and readings exceeding 0.3 Sigma at the folio edge are to be reported under the Third Concordance's Amendment XIV Clause 9; the Nine routinely exceeds this at folios 5 and 9, and the reports are routinely filed.
The bay is closed to readers on the second and fourth of each month, for cleaning. The Nine may not be removed from the press. Requests for photography are granted, and the resulting images are filed in place of the folios, which are not returned to the press until the images have been catalogued.
See also
-
MS 0224.22
On the Alignment of Instrument and Intent
On the Alignment of Instrument and Intent (commonly abbreviated as Alignment or OAI) is the foundational treatise of the regulator…
-
MS 8934.59
Directorate of Notional Alignment
The Directorate of Notional Alignment (DNA) is a sub-directorate under the Directorate of Archival Coherence, established by the 1…
-
MS 5788.96
Concordance 88
The document formally designated Concordance 88, also referred to in some filing indices as "The Crossed Quill Concordance," is a …
-
MS 3858.04
Clarification on Radial Terminology Document
The Clarification on Radial Terminology is not an independent instrument. It is an amendment to the Third Concordance, entered at …
-
MS 2636.65
Twelfth Concordance, Amendment Gamma
“… a document whose circulation is restricted to Librarians of the Fifth Codification or higher, whose existence is acknowledged o…
-
MS 0987.80
The Seventeenth Concordance Amendment
The Seventeenth Concordance Amendment refers collectively to the entirety of the authorized modifications to the foundational admi…
Referenced by
- MS 1525.22 Dreaming Atlas
- MS 1342.55 Ninth Concordance Amendment Sigma
Readers also asked
Material Filing Sigma-9: how is it conducted?
Material Filing Sigma-9 is the standing classification by which the Sigma Regulator records every quantity of Sigma-Glass and Sigma-Glass Precursor that moves between the ateliers of Annex Sigma and the dock heads of Doc…
Material Filing Sigma-9Sigma Cascade Principle: how is it conducted?
The Sigma Cascade Principle is a standing interpretive doctrine of the Librarian order holding that a sufficient density of Sigma-class objects within a single enclosed volume will induce a recursive feedback loop of spa…
Sigma Cascade PrincipleConcordance Amendment Tracking: how is it conducted?
Concordance Amendment Tracking (CAT) is the mandated administrative practice for logging the issuance, versioning, status, and interrelationship of all amendments to the Third Concordance, Ninth Concordance, Twelfth Conc…
Concordance Amendment TrackingThird Concordance: what does it set out?
The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…
Third ConcordancePassages cited from this record
-
The reader who has arrived here has done what was asked of him. Nothing further is asked.
Amendment Sigma-9, folio 6, marginal note, hand of the Sub-Registrar
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7750.84 Sigma Rated Resonance Scanner
- MS 4748.22 Clarified Chromatic Scale
Because you consulted