The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Alban Kirth

MS 2116.42 · Persons

Definition and standing

Alban Kirth is a serving member of the Office of Acquisitions Amp Stasis, attached to the Seasonal Sub-Committee since the closing of the Ninety-Second Concordance recension. Kirth is known within the Tower almost entirely for two positions advanced in committee: first, that the Bud Stage is a mislabelled overlap rather than a distinct stage; second, and more consequentially, that the Pistil Stage must precede the Stamen Stage in any catalogue that records both. Neither position has been adopted. Both have been recorded, which in the practice of the Office amounts to the same thing after enough amendments. Kirth's file carries a flat designation and no honorific, unusual for a clerk who has chaired four consecutive sessions of the Seasonal Sub-Committee. The Office does not explain this. The file notes only that Kirth was transferred from the Stacks of Acquired Matter in the year 911, with no reason entered.

The overlap argument

The Bud Stage appears in the Third Concordance, Annex 11, as a discrete developmental position with its own floor access and its own formulary. Kirth's contention, first tabled in 918 and re-tabled in 919, 921, and 924, is that the Bud Stage describes the same interval as the closing portion of the preceding stage, recorded twice under two names by two committees sitting in different winters. The evidence Kirth offers is a set of shelf-marks: forty-one pairs of holdings whose access records overlap to the hour. The counter-evidence, marshalled by the Office's Standing Defence of Nomenclature, is a single shelf-mark — No. 1947-08-3174-Alba — which does not overlap with anything and which the Defence has declined to explain. Kirth has requested that explanation seven times. The requests are logged. > "The overlap is not in doubt. What is in doubt is which of the two labels the overlap is entitled to wear." — Alban Kirth, minutes of the Seasonal Sub-Committee, session 924-C

The precedence dispute

Kirth's second position is the one that has drawn a faction. Since 920 Kirth has led a group within the Office of Acquisitions Amp Stasis arguing that the Pistil Stage must always precede the Stamen Stage. The argument rests on a reading of the Second Concordance in which the two stages are ordered by function rather than by shelf-number, and in which any catalogue listing them in reverse order is transmitting an error inherited from the transcriptors of the Waning. The faction is small — eleven names on the last roll, though the roll has not been audited since 922 — and is not recognized as a faction by the Office, which records its members as "clerks with an interest in developmental sequencing." Kirth has twice objected to this phrasing in writing. The objection is recorded and unresolved. Opposition comes chiefly from the Stamen Registry, which maintains that ordering is a matter of shelf-practice and not of development, and which has quietly begun issuing access slips in the old order whenever a Kirth-aligned clerk is not on duty.

Relation to the Resonance school

Kirth has published nothing on resonance and has declined three invitations to comment on the Alban Resonance Model. The Office has nonetheless twice referred Kirth's papers to the Resonance Technicians' Guild for "parallel review," a step whose legal basis rests on a clause of the Third Concordance that was amended in 919 and whose current text Kirth disputes. The connection is a matter of surname only. Kirth is not related to Senior Lumener Alban, to Alban Kells, or to Alban of the Thirty-Sixth Landing, and has asked that the catalogue note this. The note has been added here at Kirth's own request, filed under clerical correction 924-K.

Procedural notes

Kirth chairs the Seasonal Sub-Committee in the second month of each season. Visitors to the sub-committee's rooms are asked not to bring stamen-forms past the outer threshold; the forms are tripped by the door-weight and must be re-filed by hand. This rule was entered after the session of 923-A and is attributed to no one. Kirth's standing amendments to the Bud Stage definition remain on the docket. The docket is read at the opening of each session and closed at its end.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Alban Resonance Model: how is it conducted?

The Alban Resonance Model is a foundational, though largely superseded, acoustic-doctrinal framework. It posits that each structural void within the Tower—most notably spandrels, soffits, and certain interstitial cavitie…

Alban Resonance Model
Waning of the West Stack: what happened?

"The luminosity faded not as a curtain falls, but as a breath fades in cold air."— Initial observation log, No. 1947-08-3174-Alba, attributed to Senior Lumener Alban

Waning of the West Stack
Alban of the Thirty-Sixth Landing: who were they?

Alban of the Thirty-Sixth Landing was a Senior Lumener and notable field indexer active between Tower Years 298 and 329. His career is defined by a series of methodical, if unconventional, cataloguing expeditions, most f…

Alban of the Thirty-Sixth Landing
Alban Kells: who were they?

Alban Kells is a Scribe-Prefect and Registrar within the Somatics Collegium, currently housed in Dormitory Vault 3,302-C. His formal dormancy, entered in Y.S. 14,822, follows a period of influential, if contentious, scho…

Alban Kells
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.